Does the law create our ethics?

Question

What is the standard of ethics to judge right and wrong if laws do not create our ethic?

Answer 1

In a sense. The lawyer who said you were to stop "talking s*ite" should have thought about your question more carefully. Common law was based on the common customs of our country. So in a sense moral values created these laws. But in another sense, the individual could be led by authority (lawmakers) in deciding what is right and wrong. We call it jumping on the bandwagon. For instance individual beliefs are based on the process of socialisation. When, as a youngster, you are told that something is wrong by your parents, you tend to believe them. Not because they are correct but because a child looks up to their parent's for guidance. The case is the same for adults. Most people are "sheep" and look to the shepherd to tell them what is right and wrong. The shepherd in this case being the lawmakers (authority). People in authority are there because they can influence people. Hence, influence their judgement on what is right or wrong. This is done through various methods of manipulation, most notably the media. I suppose the question should be- who are these influences?

Answer 2

It's the other way around: there's a call for new laws when the view on the ethics change.
Like: if many people will think the punishments for crime aren't big enough, people will vote on people who want to make laws which says 'bigger punishments'. That's just an example, there are many more of those.

Even where it would seem laws dictate ethics: the laws are there in place because of the (previous) view on ethics in the first place.

Answer 3

Originally ethics created the law. The law was created because there were people who didn't abide by the ethics of the majority. And since if it isn't against their ethics, it has to be made against the law.

With fewer people attending church, the huge down swing in good manners and consideration of others, the law it getting overworked.

Answer 4

No our ethics create the law!

Answer 5

It doesn't create them but tries to enforce them. The people created ethics and then created law in order to protect our ethics.

Answer 6

ethics depend on you and your culture, its the same as morals, the law only comes into it when your ethics mean you would break the law with an action you ethics say is ok.

Answer 7

i do not comprehend the position those 'actuality' seem yet ... Bats are literally not birds. Bats are literally not "hen" … with 4 legs. Rabbits do no longer bite their very personal cud. Pi does no longer equivalent 3. The Earth isn't a circle. Rabbits do no longer have hoofs. The remedy for leprosy isn't rubbing birds blood throughout someone. The earth isn't flat. Snakes can't communicate. Donkeys can't communicate. human beings can't opt for the flow to the sky. There are lots extra "try identifying to purchase a flower. put in a dismal room. leave it there for an afternoon." you've been listening to that scamming preacher back, have not you? "Then our lord god shaped guy of dirt from the floor, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and guy became a residing being." Do you've any theory how ridiculous that sounds? HOW is it conceivable that a very grown human being interior the Western international ought to conceivable believe there are invisible creatures up interior the sky sitting about on cloudies with an order style and a pencil basically waiting for requests in the previous granting all desires to each body ... fantastically white USians? that's not something short of ludicrous. Do you smile on the African witch medical specialist spinning in circles, making incantations; imploring his gods to provide him in spite of favour he desires or needs? for sure you do; you imagine it’s basically infantile, superstitious nonsense that’s established of backward heathen natives. There you've it. To my concepts the godster thingie is not any diverse to the African witch medical specialist thingie. "ethics arent an outstanding type of info." actual. Ethics, like actuality, splendor, moral criteria and Justice are interior the eys of the beholder. ~

Answer 8

I would go further to say that it's the politicians who create the laws that determine our ethics...

Answer 9

Supposedly it's the other way around. Ethics in the form of public policy define crime.

Answer 10

no we have our own ethics. but we also have to take into consideration lawful and social ethics when we make decisions.