Why are there concerns for terrorrists prisoners held in Guantanamo Bay, they are terrorrists and not citizens

Question

Will those criticizing america and claiming that these prisoners are not terrorrists stand behind their claims and allow these prisoners to be released into their custody and live under house arrest in their own personal homes????? or do they want these released into america's society or deported back to their country to possibly attack and kill americans overseas and in the usa????

I am american japanese. My parents were imprisoned in hawaii after the attack on pearl harbor. it was only reasonable to imprison japanese citizens and american citizens of japanese descent without reason. the middle eastern and north african culture is a very inhumane, violent culture yet many americans are against holding them. This makes no sense and would let me beleive that those presenting these thoughts have learning disabilities.

Answer 1

Because those who are imprisoned are human, and are entitled to basic human rights, like a fair trial. Only the innocent would be released, so your "logic" escapes me.

Interning the Japanese and German Americans during WWII was a horribly racist crime. Everyone who belongs to a particular race is not the same - that is cruel stereotyping at its worst. You are doing exactly this.

Answer 2

The biggest problem is that many supposed "terrorists" being held. . . and often tortured, etc. . . .in Guantanamo and elsewhere are simply Middle Easterners who were plucked from the streets or their homes by 20-year-old American kids on the word of someone who, sometimes for money or for personal vendetta, etc. pointed the Americans toward them! Once picked up, they can be held indefinitely without charges against them or trial! But if you think it's ok that your own parents were imprisoned in Hawaii simply because they were of Japanese descent . . . well, then maybe this doesn't matter to you and I have to wonder why you even bothered to ask the question!

Answer 3

There are some 80 year old men that were just dumped there, I reckon more than half of everyone there are innocent.
I agree, it's just history repeating itself. Like the Holocaust, and the imprisonment of Japanese Americans in War World II.

Answer 4

How do you know they are terrorist? They've never been charged or convicted of anything.

Your Japanese heritage gives you no special insight into anything.

The fact that you resort to race bashing and abusive comments pretty much proves you learned nothing as those are the same things whites said about japanese in WWII.

Pretty pathetic really

Answer 5

If someone commits conflict crimes they are going to be held in charge by the international court, upon a searching of responsible they are going to be punished in the guidelines of the international community. A terrorist is someone who commits acts to invoke terror in a set of persons. no longer a guy who fires a weapon at yet another guy, this does no longer be a terrorist, yet a soldier with out a uniform. as an get mutually in the course of the modern conflict the patriots did not placed on uniforms, although they were battling as squaddies or militiamen. To me the time period "terrorist" as utilized by united statesa. authorities is a be conscious used to take the identity from someone so the act hostile to the guy will seem as a act hostile to a inferior human being. a form of brainwashing i'm sensible you're conscious of. I actually have heard of words used to describe jap those who proves that rule. also, with out offense meant, the "N" be conscious to describe black human beings became used to save segregation contained in the U.S. for a lengthy time period. And no offense to the Dr. who wrote previously yet some human beings earnings from the fantasy of the Apocalypse.