What was in the pie!?

Question

An aquaintance posed this question to me today:

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------


I was walking around my neighborhood today and I overheard a guy outside on his cell phone. These were his exact words: "So, did you just cut that part out or did you eat the whole pie?"

I wanted so badly to ask him, "What!? What was in the pie!? "

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Well, what do you think. What was in the pie?

Answer 1

Since he asked "did you eat the whole pie?" I wouldn't think it would be anything too gross to eat. Maybe a pet or kid licked it or someone put their finger in the pie.

Answer 2

Sometimes when baking pies or cakes from ingredients which are canned or packaged, bugs, and other unspeakable are processed by accident..

It is very easy to mix these bugs, etc into a cake or pie.

This could be the topic of that conversation., over heard from a cell phone.

Also, the person who made the pie could have placed an eatable name on the outside.which could have been eaten or cut out.

Answer 3

My first thought is a bug landed on the pie, and he was asking if he cut out the piece with bugness on it.

Answer 4

Fingers are only found in chili or McChicken salad, so not those. How about a rotted rabbit fetus or a hairy horse testacle?

Answer 5

He was just goofing around with you. He probably wasn't talking to anybody!! Neighbors like to play tricks with others on the block. lol

Answer 6

a band aid

Answer 7

I am thinking it was a pubic hair

Answer 8

rat definitely rat

Answer 9

prolly was a burnt part lol i dunno