If pupils are taught both English Lang and lit, will they get better grades in both due to consolidation?

Question

We are looking at offering English language and Literature as seperate option choices, at present students have to do both. Is there are research evidence to show that if students do both the effect of consolidation of key skills present in both subjests results in better results in both. Or are students just as likely to get a good grade if they only study the one subject?

Answer 1

I didnt do Eng Lit at all, but I got top grades in my Eng Language exams. But then I did a lot of reading because I loved to do it anyway. I think the Lit would consolidate the Language, giving students a wier knowledge of writing styles...;

Answer 2

I was taught both at school, and Latin basics. These complimentary studies were beneficial to each other, One needs to understand the language, its forms and usage in order to appreciate literature and writers styles, whilst literature enhances ones vocabulary, exposing you to more varied words and how to use them.
As to evidence of there successes and faillures, I can only say that private schools in the UK teach both to all students, whilst state schools only teach generic English, and I know which produce the better qualifications at the end.

Answer 3

some of the skills and topics e.g shakespeare and how the language potrays a certain theme, are interrelated. i am a gcse student who doesa leve english lit at school @ the same time as eng lang + lit and this is what i found

Answer 4

I have found that they need something to go with the language, but depending on ability this could be Media or just some non-examined literary work. I wouldn't like people to 'opt out' because to me that is like cutting out (for example) algebra from the rest of maths.

Answer 5

i went to a school where they taught both separately and not together, and i myself did english language alone, which i felt was beneficial as you got to focus on the one you wanted to most, and i feel it is more easier to digest as it is one separate subject. However, i know schools that do both together and it does have its advantage as it gives you the option to study both, but i feel that if you are going to specialise in one such as at university like i am, then having it separate it more recognised.

Answer 6

I cant see as it would make any difference really,so whats the point in changing things now?