when do you think a country needs a communist goverment?

Answer 1

When people get tired of basing their existences on creating wealth for a very few and pursuing happiness through material goods.

Read "Woman on the Edge of Time" by Marge Piercy for an idea.

Be different from 99% of your fellow citizens and actually read Marx before critiquing him.

Be different than 99% of your fellow citizens and learn how the Soviet Union was merely state run capitalism. Read Tzevetan Todorov's analysis of Stalin.


Class warfare is outsourcing American jobs to increase corporate profits.

Class warfare is turning a blind eye to American companies hiring illeagal workers, then going on right-wing radio to decry illeagal immigration.

Class warfare is the median household income of America remaining stagnant while CEO salaries skyrocket.

Class warfare is sending other people's children to die in Iraq while your's party in Georgetown.

Class warfare is Jack Welch accepting a $250 million retirement while General Electric cut health benefits and laid off workers.

Class warfare is cutting spending for student loans and grants while giving tax breaks for the top wealth holders.

Class warfare is already happening. The upper classes have declared war on the rest of us and we are helping them bleed us dry. Read theories on hegemony to understand why.

Answer 2

A communist form of government will only work conceivably for very small tight-knit religious communities or tribal societies in the same way a pure democracy could work for them.. Take the Amish for example. They live life according to a form of "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need" kind of system. The Amish, however, are very religiously dedicated people who simply want to live their own lives without having a political agenda. Certain forms of communism will only work for those people.

But you know when communism won't work? It certainly won't work when you try to have a communist government for a whole country. And you know what else? It certainly won't work for a bunch of spoiled liberal college students who smoke too much pot and think Che Guevera is the greatest hero of all time. To you pill popping college Marxists, get a real job and realize that the form of government you want will never come to fruition.

Answer 3

When the country has lost the capacity to reason and instead relies on "feelings".

When it measures success by intentions rather than results.

When it is full of victims.

When no one will take responsibility for the choices they make.

Answer 4

Not communist government a socialist government would be better for poor countries. because lack of a solid economic stucture.

Answer 5

Communism is based on the Utopian concept of socialism. The reality to Utopia is that as long as human beings are involved, there is no chance of Utopia, and there is no "equal rights for all".

Answer 6

When all the greedy corporations and banks run the country and tell the President what to do.Oh i guess it's time for the U.S. to turn Commie.

Answer 7

When the citizens have lost the will to live and the ability to think for themselves.

Answer 8

When the citizens of a country decide they want it.

Answer 9

When people are ready to send people who won't work to jail.

Answer 10

Whenever its people get tired of their country having any sort of succcess.