if a tree falls in the forest with noone around...does it still make a noise??

Question

just vundering....

Answer 1

Of course. How did it fall down in the first place? Chuck Norris was practicing his round-house kicks and knocked it down!!!

Answer 2

Yes. There are still creatures in the forest that depend on their hearing to survive. When a tree trunk or branch snaps, it's a loud noise, and that's kind of like natures way of telling everything around, not just people, to watch out.

Answer 3

I'm sure it does make a noise, but the thing is that if no one is there to hear it then you can't say it did. It's as if a tree falls and there's no one around, then it didn't fall because no one saw it....it didn't happen because how would you know it did if you weren't there. You obviously can not say a tree just fell if no one was there although it did fall.

Answer 4

Yeah Doug fell over very last week and he nonetheless hasnt stoppped screaming. Does it created reverbitations contained in the air because it strikes by it? sure of route it does, for it now to not make any sound there might want to must be no air, a vacuum. For there to be a vacuum there, then the tree wouldnt were waiting to live on because it wouldnt have air.

Answer 5

You can stop vundering, YES.

Answer 6

That is a question that cannot be answered because it cannot be proven. It can have a theory though. That would be like saying which came first. the chicken or the egg.

Answer 7

No, it doesn't. You can't have a sound without an ear to hear it. Otherwise it is just the movement of air.

Answer 8

Sure it does, there is just no one around to hear it. Just because no one hears it dosen't mean there is no sound, ask the birds and the bees.

Answer 9

vell dude.....of course it does, just think abt it, does it make noise bcs there is someone there, or bcs of its impact vith the ground...vell?vat u say?

yea very vell....lol

Answer 10

no real way to prove it so no one really knows