Tom Brady .vs. Peyton Manning?

Question

both QB's have proven time and time again they are the best? which one will hit the hall of fame first and WHY???

Answer 1

Both of them will go into the Hall of Fame. Brady due to 3 Super Bowl wins and Manning due to breaking almost every QB record besides a few still held by Marino. Like another person mentioned. It's going to depend on which one retires first. Brady's arm has been hurting him all season, so he might be the first of the two to retire. However, all it takes is one wrong hit or fall to put a QB out of commission. Both quarterbacks are pretty durable, but I'd have to give Manning an edge as far as durability. He has yet to miss a game or hardly even a play due to injuries. More likely that not, they'll probably get initiated the same year, knowing how the rivalry is between them and how they are good friends.

Answer 2

I strongly believe that Peyton Manning will def hit the hall of fame first..... He has shown that he can take charge... he pretty much holds the team and coaches the offense... he is also the offenses support mentally. He will hold them together and has done so along with the help of Dungy. Brady is an excellent quarterback as well... but I think Peyton will be first in the hall of fame..... as a matter of fact, I think Peyton will also become a pro football coach when he retires playing the game.

Answer 3

Tom Brady will hit the hall of fame first because of the three super bowls that he has brought the New England Patriots and the fact that so far Peyton Manning has not yet won one. Peyton may beat Tom Brady statistically but the point of an Nfl quaterback is to bring your team to success and success is measured in super bowls. Therefore it's Tom Brady 3> Peyton Manning 0.

Answer 4

Depends who retires first. Peyton has the Stats and will likely go in on first Ballot. Brady has shown he is a team player and knows how to lead, he has the rings as well. He has done it on a no-name team for the most part and come on his best WR Deion Branch isn't even a number one in Seattle, I think he ended up like 2 or 3. He spreads the ball though and doesn't really need a number one. I think he goes in on his first ballot no problem as well. So unless they retire the same year it depends when they retire.

Answer 5

Given their play to date they will both be inducted into the HOF. Probably Brady will be inducted first but they will both get in on the first ballot. We may have seen the best of Brady but Peyton is coming into his prime. Peyton so far is more durable than Brady. It will be interesting to see just how serious an injury Brady has to his throwing shoulder. Who knows though in that Montana survived 'Tommy John' surgery to his throwing elbow and still put up impressive numbers afterwards,
As far as Peyton, I feel confident he will get his ring.

Answer 6

Depends simply on who retires first, I believe. Both should get in first crack they have.

Manning, similar to Marino, is destined to get in on his stats and legend alone.

Brady, though will never show the stats of Manning, is likely to get in due to his leading the Pats to 3 of 4 Super Bowls (although we could still see more from him as he's not that old yet).

Answer 7

well it shows that both are really good and is just like the others say woh will retired first if its peyton manning or brady but they will make it. I just have more confident that brady whould because he has 3 superbowl rings don you think? how many does petyon have

Answer 8

Both of them will be in the HOF. It's just a matter of which player retires first. Both of them will go in on the first ballot.

Answer 9

Tom Brady... go patriots u got alot of work to do but you'll pul thru

Answer 10

they'll both get in at the same time on the same ballot if they both retire at the same time otherwise whoever retire first will get in first