If you have an apple tree and an apple falls in your neighbor's yard, who does the apple belong to?

Answer 1

Same as if the tree falls on their house and destroys their garage, it's their apple and their mess. It's an act of God. Insurance companies see it that way anyway. If it wasn't theirs...consider raking the apple tree's leaves off their yard.

Answer 2

Where I live it would be the neighbor's apple because it fell on his or her side of the fence. When branches grow over a neighbor's side of the fence the neighbor has the right to cut them to the fence line. The neighbor is also responsible for cleaning up the leaves from that same tree that fall into his or her yard.

Answer 3

Your neighbor of course. If the apple fell and hit your neighbor on the head would you want to run over and claim the apple?

Answer 4

Neighbors

Answer 5

Because the apple is no longer a part of the tree it belongs to whoevers land it falls on.

Answer 6

often, any branches of a tree becoming over your belongings line are considered honest sport for the neighbor to do what they please with them. If the apple grew to become into becoming on a branch interior the neighbor's backyard, it particularly is often regularly occurring that or no longer it particularly is okay for him to take it and save it. He ought to even trim returned the branches to the place they have been returned in the back of his belongings line. people try this each and all of the time.

Answer 7

The neighbor! Possesion is 9/10 of the law!

Answer 8

It belongs to your neighbor if the part of the tree it fell from, hangs over his yard.

Also any part of the tree that hangs over your neighbors yard can be trimmed by your neighbor without your permission.

Answer 9

The neighbor owns the apple but your liable for any damages...sometimes is sucks to be in a country with such a vigorous legal system :)

Answer 10

I dont know i would give it to the neighbor let them have its just an apple..