Do you think teachers....?

Question

...should tell their students their personal opinions on such things as politics and whatnot? I personally dont think they should. For one thing, it can mislead students to be biased to a certain standpoint when they need to decide things themselves. I dont think it's smart to say who they vote for and stuff.

Answer 1

No, because it's not right for teachers to influence students to believe what they believe. Also, if a teacher was, say, Buddhist, and a student was say, Christian, or if the teacher was, say Democratic, and she talked about how she felt about the President, it might upset the student that the teacher is so different and that might be what they focus on instead of learning from the teacher. We tend to look down on people who's religions are different, and if a student looks down at a teacher, how's he or she going to learn anything? If the student is mad at what the teacher said to attack the President, wouldn't that take away from the concentration on the lesson?

My social studies teacher said that his goal was to not let anyone find out what he believes, if anything, or his political party, if he has one.That way, we will only judge him as an intelligent teacher instead of what he believes.

Answer 2

This is a sticky subject, but an important one. I once had my students write about how important religion was in their lives because we were about to read Elie Wiesel's Night. One student asked if I could do that, and I answered, "Of course I can! As long as I'm not telling you WHAT to believe."

I do not hide my own inclinations when asked. I will concede I am Methodist and can be talked into conceding that I am a Democrat if it becomes relevant. In my classes we often discuss such topics as immigration and war, and it is probably pretty obvious where I fall on these issues. However, I try my darnedest to be sure reasonable arguments are heard from both sides and that students can make their own choices at the end.

In short, I do believe that ballots are to remain secret overall, but I do believe it is worth sharing and *exchanging* informed opinions with young people.

Answer 3

As students move on to high school and college they can make their own opinions on topics such as politics, and i believe that it is necessary for the students to be exposed to what the real world is and how people have differing opinions on various topics. The statements of their opinions allows for discussion and debate which will help them in the real world. In High School and College the students are not going to take a teachers opinion and automatically say that because it is what their teacher says it must be true and make it their own opinion on a topic. So no I do not believe that teachers (high school and up) should keep their mouths shut on topics that will allow for discussion and allow the students to get ready for what they will face in the future.

Answer 4

I'm an EFL teacher but I teach foreign teenagers and adults so it's slightly different than teaching little kids. I wouldn't tell my students who I vote for. A general discussion on politics is fine and if they ask my opinion I tell them but without going into specifics. Discussions with teenagers on these issues is a good thing though and it's amazing how insightful they are.

Answer 5

Teachers are not supposed to give our opinions on politics or religion. We are told specifically not to do this. I have students who sometimes want to know my opinion on a political or religious issue/topic and I always tell them that I am staying out of it. I was just asked who I voted for and I refused to say. I think it is a good idea for teachers to stay out of it for several reasons.

Answer 6

In the US, the teachers should present all sides of an issue. But if you are a teacher in say North Korea, you are resorted to teaching how Kim Jung Il invented the light bulb while overthrowing the capitalistic demons...

Teachers ultimately have a standard they have to teach towards, and that is usually dictated by who is paying them.

Answer 7

Only if the students have genuine desire to know their opinion and only if it relates to the subject matter. I could see it in a civics class, but politics has no place in say, a science course.

Answer 8

a youthful lady instructor with obvious liberal dispositions explains to her class of toddlers that she is an atheist. She asks her class in the event that they're atheists too. not likely understanding what atheism is yet desirous to be like their instructor, their hands explode into the air like fleshy fireworks. there is, even with the undeniable fact that, one exception. a alluring lady named Lucy has not long previous alongside with the group. the instructor asks her why she has desperate to be diverse. "through fact i'm not an atheist." Then, asks the instructor, "What are you?" "i'm a Christian." the instructor is a sprint perturbed now, her face extremely pink. She asks Lucy why she is a Christian. "nicely, i become reported understanding and loving Jesus. My mom is a Christian, and my dad is a Christian, so i'm a Christian." the instructor is now indignant. "that is not any reason," she says loudly. "What if your mom become a moron, and your dad become a moron. What might you be then?" She paused, and smiled. "Then," says Lucy, "i may well be an atheist." ......................................... instructor: the place is your homework? student: I lost it scuffling with this toddler who reported you were not the suitable instructor interior the college ......................................... the instructor spent the great hour examining to her class on the subject of the bison family individuals. while she had finished, she reported, “call some issues that are very risky to get close to and function horns.” Little Johnny spoke up with out hesitation, “automobiles?” ......................................... a sprint boy merely could not study. sometime his instructor asked him who signed the statement of Independence. He did not understand. for tremendously much a week she asked him an identical question daily, yet nevertheless he could not arise with the suitable suited answer. finally, in desperation, she referred to as the boy's father to her workplace. "Your boy won't tell me who signed the statement of Independence," she complained. "Come here, son, and sit down," the dad reported to the boy. "Now in case you signed that loopy factor, merely admit it as a thank you to get out of here!"

Answer 9

,I don't share my opinions but it doesn't matter, what the kids bring home gets twisted and parents are always misunderstanding and calling the school..on everyone, it seems.
There are a lot of teachers at my school who are highly opinionated!

Answer 10

No, because I would automatically take their same position to kiss @ss.