im trading marion barber and keyshawn johnson for brett favre is this a good trade?

Question

here is a look at my team
QB Ben Roethlisberger
wR Terrell Owens
WR Darrell Jackson
WR Keyshawn Johnson
RB Tiki Barber
RB Fred Taylor
TE L.J. Smith
BN Braylon Edwards
BN Marion Barber III
BN Byron Leftwich
BN Sage Rosenfels

I am making the trade with the league commish....i is starting bulger at qb

Answer 1

Make this trade !!!

You really need help at QB and Brett will help tons...

if you make the trade I would drop both Leftwich and Rosenfels to free up spots for some other players you can pick up ....

Good luck !!!

Answer 2

this is an extremely good trade. you need QB help and are giving up backups you'll never use(Edwards is better than Keyshawn). also, Favre has an amazing fantasy playoff schedule.

As a matter of fact, this trade seems way too one-sided and that you are probably trading with a team who is giving up players for nothing, i.e., this trade. Brett Favre is the number 8 QB in fantasy. Keyshawn is maybe the #18 WR and Barber isn't sniffing top 30 RB. If you're making this trade with a team dumping his players, don't do it and then call attention to this with your commissioner or whoever can stope it. This is very unethical and believe me, the fantasy football gods will get cheaters back.

Now, if this trade is just and fair, then have at it and good luck.

Answer 3

No do not do that! Trust me I know the most from everyone! Marion Barber is getting in there more and will score more touchdowns. Keyshawn is being used as a weapon and is a big target in the endzone. Favre is old and you never know what is going to happen to him. He could get injured for the season. I suggest getting rid of roethhlisberger. Dont get rid of darrell jackson because seattle have injured recievers so they'll go to him. Try getting rid of taylor and roethlisberger for a good qb. Ask me if your going to try to do that trade so I can help you. Then bump up barber at the 2nd rb. Hope u listen!!

Answer 4

At this point yes.. because sage and byron will not help you as much and big ben he is doing real bad this point brett would be a good pickup because keyshawn and marion barber arnt needed as much as i can see in your line up.

Answer 5

Yeah you need serious help at QB. Barber will get some goal line touches, but Romo Really likes TO near the Goal line.

Answer 6

definetely do the commerce. Peyton is going to be high-quality. you'll purely favor a backup qb for perhaps the first common season interest or perhaps as the Colts are on bye...if Peyton and Favre are both heatlhy very hardly ever might want to you take advantage of Favre