is gary sheffield a hall of famer?

Question

he needs 45 more hrs to get to 500 career homers........500 hr's is usually a gateway to the hall of fame........what do u guys think?

the question is will he be a future hall of famer?

Answer 1

No, he is NOT a Hall of Famer

The way he has forced trades via poor play and bad attitude I believe has killed that thought.

I also must disagree... I do not think 500 home runs is an automatic invite anymore, especially amongst players of this "enhanced" era.

After all, Rafael Palmeiro has 569 HRs and over 3,000 hits, Sosa has 588 HRs, and Big Mac has 583.

Which one of them do you see getting in at any time soon?

OH, and IF he squeeks in... it will NOT be as a Yankee, (his stats there were mediocre at best.) he'll go in as a Brave.

Answer 2

he's about 2 seasons away from 500 homers and 6 seasons from 3000 hits if he can average 150 per year. the hits may be a stretch but 500 homers and say 2750 hits with a near 300 avg is pretty good. he'll be a second or 3rd ballot guy and he'll be wearing a florida marlins hat. mark my words on that. when with the marlins he was a winner and the only time in his career he was happy. until now that is.

Answer 3

Don't listen 2 some of those {smart guy's}. 2 tell you the truth i think he will be the exception, he will hit 500 homers but i dont think it will make him a hall of famer, because i think of him as a good player but not a famer, it's kinda hard 2 explain, but i hope u understan what im trying 2 say.Final answer NO.

Answer 4

Sheffield left the Yankees in a commerce with the Detroit Tigers. He become unhappy with being a DH, and had to play the sector (you realize, like a genuine baseball participant). He have been given his desire while the Tigers released him before everything of the 2009 season, and he become signed with the help of the Mets presently thereafter. He become granted unfastened corporation on the top of the 2009 season, and no person become interested in keeping his centers. He did not announce his retirement until these days (February 2011), yet on condition that he's performed through fact the 2010 season, he could be eligible for the corridor of repute in 2015. there is not any doubt that he merits to be voted in, he become between the greater suitable ability hitters for a whole decade, and has the "magic" form of 500 HRs (as nicely to a pair different very remarkable stats). even with the undeniable fact that, the vote casting for induction is finished with the help of a set of capricious hypocrytes... so as that they might bypass over Sheffield the two through fact he admitted to utilising PEDs, or through fact he become not cherished. plenty for honesty paying for forgiveness. i might vote him in in the event that they gave me a vote.

Answer 5

Hall of Very Good, maybe. His attitude ruins his chance for the Hall of Fame

Answer 6

he wants to play 3 more years which if that happens he will get 500 hrs which is usually enough to get to the hof. i say yes even though i hate sheffield

Answer 7

without the 45 more homeruns he's not a hall of famer

Answer 8

Yeah...as much as I hate to say it...he probably is a future HOFer.

Damn shame though IMO. Pete Rose is banned from the HOF for betting on baseball...but Sheff will go in even though he openly admitted to purposely making errors to force the Brewers to trade him years ago. That constitues "throwing games" in my eyes.

Answer 9

He's NOT a first ballot HOFer, but will probably get in. He's played alot of years at a high level.

Answer 10

Not likely.. too bad he's going in to the next season with an injured wrist. Some people just dont know how to quit while they're ahead...