Who is the best judge on the x factor, i think it has to be Simon?

Answer 1

Simon is the cutting edge of the show - he's honest, and his judgements are absolutely spot on each week. He is a razor-sharp judge of vocals and performance. Sharon not so much, but I do get the feeling she genuinely cares for the singers.

Louis I find a bit monotonous, and I wonder sometimes if his heart is in it. When Nikitta questioned him about what WOULD be a good song for her, he just waffled a load of vague rubbish, dodn't give her a helpful answer at all. When he lost two groups in two shows, he didn't seem that bothered. I would have been gutted.

Answer 2

I never understood what that Sharon woman was diong being a judge on X-factor. For me, Simon and Louis are the ones that know the business. Although, this year I'm a bit sick of the show.

Answer 3

I out of the three of them Simon is the best. If you could put Simon's judgement and Sharon's compassion together then you would have a perfect judge. Louis does nothing for the contestants, the show or me.

Answer 4

Simon because he tells it as he sees it, there’s no point in giving people false hope and he does not play up to the camera. Sharon is nice but sometimes can be a drama queen. Louis in the previous series more or less agreed with everything Sharon said, (I think it’s because she empties her cups of water on him anytime she disagrees with him). But now, he seems to be after Simon’s job and sometimes sounds harsh.

Simon is the best and his opinion is generally respected and he knows it too.

Answer 5

I think it has to be Louis Walsh because his groups have done much better than Simon's or Sharon's have. Westlife, Boyzone, Girl's Aloud and last years x-factor winner Shane Ward.
Also because he can stick up for himself when the other judges pick a fight with him and he does not let what they say get to him.
Simon is very rude to the contestants and Sharon is only on the show because of her famous husband

Answer 6

No way I have to totally disagree with everyone!!! Are ye not sick of listening to Simon's usual hurtful lines? Get over it Simon, it's not funny anymore. I'm all for him telling the truth, but sometimes you can nearly physically see the contestants hearts breaking. If he didn't like the song/performance that's all he has to say without humiliating the poor people on stage. Louis is my favourite. He will say he didn't like it without making the singers feel suicidal!He knows what he's talking about.(Westlife. Boyzone, Girls Aloud) Simon inflicted the Cheeky girls on us for God's sake!! I've never heard Sharon tell anyone in the live show that she didn't like it? not very constructive. Anyway that's my opinion. Louis all the way!!

Answer 7

Simon blatently!

He is one of the best known in the business!!!

Sharon - whats she there for???!! coz shes married to Ozzy???????

and Louis - he's alright - but he hasn't done as well in his career as Simon has.

Although i dont agree with everything Simon says he is 99% of the time right!!!!

Answer 8

I agree with you, I think Simon is the best!!! At least he's honest to the contestants. Sharon is lovely but she can get a bit "emotional" and Louis just contradicts himself (he told Ray to stop doing swing and then told Ben that he should stick to doing the "rock" thing - he really should make up his mind).

Answer 9

I think simon is the one who tells it as it is if your good or not,i like sharon and louis too there nice and more sympathetic to the contestants.

Answer 10

Yer def Simon.. he tells the truth... the other 2 just say what you want to here!!

N im fed up of hearing.. uv picked the wrong song Simon!!!

Come on find a new Line Louis!!