Top Chef Fans?

Question

Is it just me or does anyone else think Betty should have been eliminated last night?

Answer 1

Yes she should have been eliminated.The reason is that she knew about the rule of not altering the recipe the next day.She was told just like everyone else.She can't claim she didn't know.Betty and the rest of them will be watched alot more closely to make sure there isn't any more cheating.

Answer 2

No but I do think that she would have been if she had told the entire truth.

When you watched the shopping trip you hear her say "We should make a pizza." In the judging room she lets the other guy say it was his idea. If she had said it was her idea they would have given her a third victory. Then, they would have heard about the cookies and had to get rid of her.

Personally, I would have exited the two teams that sat there at the judge's table. They all made allegations that they did not substantiate. That is unprofessional. I would get rid of them all.

Betty was honest about what she did. They lied about what they saw and did. Unacceptable.

Answer 3

I don't believe that she should have. She really thought what she was doing was okay. It's not like she just added ingredients to the recipe, she removed the egg whites and added the extra sugar. Other contestants were using extra olive oil as well, so you couldn't just eliminate her. I think what they did was fair for everyone.

Answer 4

HAVEN'T SEEN LAST NIGHT'S EPISODE, BUT ISN'T BETTY FROM SEASON 1 THAT HAD TO LEAVE BECAUSE OF HER FATHER DYING? IF SO I THINK SHE IS ALOT BETTER THAN SHE WAS THEN. MORE SOFTER AROUND THE EDGES.

OK I JUST THE EPISODE FROM LAST NIGHT AND I THINK SINCE THE TEAM HAD SPOKE TO THE NUTRITIONIST AND THEY WERE ALSO BELOW THE CALORIES, SHE COULD HAVE MISUNDERSTOOD ABOUT ADJUSTING THE INGREDENTS.