Caddy for Colston?

Question

I'm in a 12 team league, and i traded Caddy williams for Marques Colston, good trade or bad trade?

Here's my team before the trade:

C Pennington
E Manning
C Williams
J Addai
R Brown
C Chambers
R Wayne
D' Stallworth
J Wiggins
L.J. Smith
L Tynes
M Stover
D Colts
D Bengals

Answer 1

Yes, Colston is Bree's go-to receiver. Especially do it if you're in a yahoo league, where you can play Colston as a TE.

Answer 2

Man, that's an awesome trade. Marques Colston is a beast. He starting in the place of Laverneus Coles on my team. Cadillac Williams sucks. I'm surprised whoever you traded with was that stupid. Good trade by you. See if you can steal some more players from him. Try trading away Daunte Stallworth and Joseph Addai or something.

Answer 3

It's a good trade, but not for your team. You've got three WR's who are must starts. Colston is a bit of an upgrade over any of them but not by much. Stallworth will regain his first two weeks form, he just had his BYE and his hamstring is healthy. Marvin is Marvin. And it looks like Miami's passing game is getting off the ground.

Also, RB's get injured. Keeping Cadillac on your bench in case someone goes down is a good idea.

If you are a top team don't make the trade. If you need the couple of extra points from Colston to make a push for the playoffs then do it. If you are safe to make the playoffs don't do it. If you make it and don't have a backup RB and one of your starters gets injured, you will be done.

Answer 4

I would definitely make this trade because you clearly have depth at RB and Colston brings a huge advantage because he is a flex player that can be used as either a TE or WR. He is the highest scorer among TE's and is the 4th highest WR. This is a no brainer as Cadillac is having nowhere near the year that Colston is having.

Answer 5

It is a very good trade for you if your getting Colston. He has emerged as one of the best WRs in Fantasy football and he is also TE eligable. In addition Caddliac Williams is having a horrid season in part due to Tampa Bays offense.

Answer 6

Good trade. You're a little weak @ RB, but Caddy wouldn't have helped you much anyway. Hopefully Addai will pick it up. Now that you have Colston, look in your league and see who's weak @ WR or QB but strong @ RB with good reserves. I'd pair up one of your QB's with Chambers and try to get a stud RB.

Answer 7

GREAT TRADE CONSIDERING COLSTON GIVES YOU WR #'S AT TE. HOWEVER, YOU PROBABLY SHOULD HAVE WORKED A DEAL TO HELP YOU RB SLOT. 3 TE'S WILL DO YOU NO GOOD. IF YOU COULD HAVE PACKAGED SMITH, CADDY TO GET COLSTON AND A RB, THAT WOULD HAVE BEEN NICE.

Answer 8

idk its tough b/c ur RB are terrible and so are ur WR so its a coin flip. Colston is more of a proven guy then Cadilac so i guess its fair. But man you need some help with this team.

Answer 9

great trade