English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

I've heard the arguement against the gas chamber theory . What evidence is there to support that there was in fact gas chambers that killed around six million jews . Don't quote some old history book , everyone knows , history is the lie the winners of wars agree upon . I want hear evidence .

2006-11-07 04:57:07 · 15 answers · asked by jsjmlj 5 in Arts & Humanities History

most lie when being tortured .

2006-11-07 05:01:06 · update #1

no one offering a good arguement or evidence yet . if you don't like the question , don't answer it . name callers are being reported . can millions be fooled ?

2006-11-07 05:25:35 · update #2

what's the least reliable kind of evidence in a court case ? ask a lawyer , eye witness accounts .

2006-11-07 05:28:15 · update #3

what's with all you haters ? all i asked for was evidence . you all assume that i'm some nazi or something . when you assume you make an ASSofUandME , but mostly you .

2006-11-07 06:04:15 · update #4

15 answers

You turn down testimonies and historical researches... What evidence WILL satisfy you, then?

Eichman had given information about it, and so had Höß (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rudolf_H%C3%B6%C3%9F) with his long, direct and detailed testamony.
~But they were under a threat, of course, so their testemony does not worth a thing, right?~

Kurt Gerstein, an SS member (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurt_Gerstein), gave plenty of information about the gas chambers during the war itself, after he saw them in action with his own eyes. No one listened to him, of course, but it was known back then too.
~Oh, but then again, he must have been crazy, or a liar, right?~

The chambers were tested time and again and it was indeed proven that those walls absorbed Zyklon B gas. If you'll go to one of the death camps in Poland (like I did), you will see the clear traces of gas in the chambers, as it becomes green when touches lime.
~Oh, sorry, I forgot. The walls of the chambers were faked by the "history-revisers", the winners~

Well, what would you say about the Sonderkommandos? What do you have to say about the testemonies and stories of the Jews who were forced to work in the death camps?
I knew a man that was a Sonderkommando in Auschwitz, and he told me that one of their jobs was to get the huge mass of corpses out of the chambers, separate between them (as they were all entangled, after their long struggle for air) and cremate them in the incinerator.
Can you think of a reason not to believe these testemonies? Of course you can. When one does not want to believe in something, he'll turn a blind eye for every piece of evident evidence.

You see, I don't buy your naivete and I don't believe your question is that honesdt as you're trying to present it.
If you were really into this interesting subject, you wouldn't oppose so much to the evidences and your answerers and you wouldn't write "gas chambers", with these insulting apostrophes.

2006-11-07 20:09:18 · answer #1 · answered by yotg 6 · 1 0

Humans are no more than animals, except for the fact that we have a sole, something to tell us right from wrong. This did take place, the death camps. It is hard for some to realize this took place while I was a child, about 60 years ago.You would think that with the advancements humans have made we would not be so savage, but we are still the humans of long ago. The people today, that is what is frighting, are no better than that. If there was a button that someone could push, that would completely destroy a race of people, someone would push it. I saw some film footage, taken in a death camp, by Nazi photographers of people lined up to go into a gas chamber. A child of about 3 years was crying after her mother, one of the Nazi guards raised his rifle and shot the little girl. Do you think he would have a problem of opening the gas valve. What I have a problem with a question like this is trying to figure out why someone would try to deny this happened.

2016-05-22 07:45:17 · answer #2 · answered by Jeanette 4 · 0 0

... right, you don't want to hear the evidence because evidence is the lie of the winners. History books tend to do crazy things like interview people who lived through it, show pictures, relate the discovery of mass graves with mounds of ash and bone fragments, document rooms full of nothing but prosthetics.

If nothing else, read the book "Ordinary Men," the account of individuals who actually took part in the Holocaust (though not the gas chambers themselves).

A better question would have been "what is the evidence that the holocaust never happened," which could have easily been answer with "there is none" rather than "good lord man, there are entire museums and libraries dedicated to nothing but the evidence!"

2006-11-07 05:05:05 · answer #3 · answered by Thought 6 · 9 0

This question shows a complete disregard for the feelings of the descendants of those who lived and/or died during the holocaust. Unfortunately this history is NOT THE LIE the WINNERS of wars agree upon. The holocaust, particularly the gas chambers, is an embarrassing chapter in the history of mankind.

2006-11-07 05:58:57 · answer #4 · answered by Jamie 4 · 7 0

The prosecutors at Nuremburg produced bills of lading from the pharmaceutical conglomerate IG Farben, showing the delivery of 4 1/2 tons of Zyclon-B per month to the SS during the latter stages of WWII. The directors of IG Farben were squirming on the stand trying to explain their sale.

The pictures of gas chambers and stories of the survivors are also well documented.

2006-11-07 05:24:56 · answer #5 · answered by Its not me Its u 7 · 5 0

They found the actual gas chambers. They still exist. As do used and unused cyanide containers.

Physical evidence = proof

2006-11-07 06:52:31 · answer #6 · answered by Barrett G 6 · 2 0

look up the real holcaust survivors and ask them if it was real, there is documented archived evidence also, rent schindlers list at the end of the movie the real actor walked hand and hand with the real person look up these people ask them if it was all a figment of their imaginations
go to barnes and noble there are nazi books I cant remember the title but I have one myself, the nazis bragged and celebrated the horrible things they did and there are also copies of letters and photos of the proud nazis in front of their tortured and dead victims, this ignorant disinformation is usually generated by kukluxklan types ,hello was world war 2 was real and hitler was an enemy it was not an international delusion

2006-11-07 05:01:11 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 6 0

The Nazis meticulously documented their crimes. There are literally thousands of pages of lists of names from all of Europe of people who were shipped to concentration camps.
You can go to the National Archives and spend days looking at the names.

The hard evidence is in eyewitness accounts of people who actually committed these crimes and witnessed them first hand.

2006-11-07 05:11:45 · answer #8 · answered by parrotjohn2001 7 · 6 0

I think one of the chambers still exists as part of the Auschwitz tour.

Personally, I think there is an extra hot spot in the circles of hell for anyone who would belittle the pain and suffering of those people who were there.

2006-11-07 05:10:59 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 5 0

So you want evidence that supports an idea you want to believe. History does not work that way. Maybe you should tell us where you just recently heard such information...I know where it comes from.

2006-11-07 05:30:11 · answer #10 · answered by Dust in the Wind 7 · 3 0

fedest.com, questions and answers