What is the solution of Kashmir issue?

Question

lets see what young and educated indians think about one of the most controversial piece of land on earth.Answer with heart and mind as well.

Answer 1

First i would want to tell about the plebiscite thing.

UN Security Council resolutions 38-40, and particularly the resolution of August 13, 1948, said that Pakistan had attacked Kashmir, and ordered Pakistan to withdraw its forces and its tribals (those were disguised as tribals but they were pak army men). Pakistan has yet to obey UN Security Council and withdraw from lands (now called POK, Pak Occupied Kashmir) controlled illegally.

UN Resolution: Jan 5, 1949
Called for three actions in this sequential order
(1) FIRST, Pakistan must withdraw all its troops and all non-Kashmiris from Kashmir.
(2) NEXT India should withdraw bulk of its troops RETAINING those required for law and order; all those who had left Kashmir (on both sides) as refugees should be allowed to return.
AND ONLY THEREAFTER ascertain the wishes of the Kashmiri people in both portions of Kashmir under UN supervision.

Pakistan violated the UN Resolution
Pakistan is non-compliant: has not withdrawn its occupied forces thereby violated the first of the 3 actions outlined by the UN resolution.
ON the contrary India has only permitted Kashmiris to own land in India’s Kashmir per Article 170 of the Indian Constitution and per UN resolution.
So plebiscite can happen only when Pak complies with the UN resolutions.

Now for the answer. Neither India nor Pakistan is going to give an inch of either side Kashmir. And ONLY ASSUMING that kashmir is given to pakistan, do u think that their army will be satisfied? Their basis for existence is being anti-india. They just want to use kashmir as a base for a larger objective of destroying India and converting it into a Islamic theocracy. Moreover Pakistan has by terror driven out about 600,000 kashmiri pandits and infiltrated the place with ISI people.

And joint mgmt; with the serious trust deficit and in the current scenario that will be possible only when the sun starts rising from the west. I think nothing will be possible until the army / ISI is ruling Pak. The army in Pakistan does not want a solution to the Kashmir issue. That is the only way they can stay in power for an eternity. This issue can only be resolved when democracy comes to Pakistan.
And Pakistan also goes on the path of economic development rather than an anti-india stance. Currently the army does not want to do even economic dealings and put all issues in the back burner unless Kashmir is solved. Kashmir will be solved according to the pak army only when they take over the entire valley. But that of course will never happen.


So after real democracy is in place (in pak) the most practical solution according to me is to make the current L.O.C the international border.


For a more detailed history as to what happened in Kashmir go the following link:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index;_ylt=AmbGHr2o1j7_Db7RQZwkzGrsy6IX?qid=20061027090208AAKJBnP

Answer 2

India is a peace country why we are fighting for land. Just make an election in kashmir with the help of UN study what people thinking if they believe in India then ask pakistan to hand over Asad Kashmir.

If they like Pakistan hand over Srinagar to them. If they are not ready make a war with them and solve.

Answer 3

Are you asking appropriate to the an prolonged time previous possession subject or the ''ongoing violence'' subject brother? we are spending extravagantly on Kashmir and correctly ought to do away with it, IF in any respect there replaced into actual answer in so giving freely to somebody - locals, Pakis or chinese language or in proportion to ''bidders''. however the peoblem isn't basically Kashmir, in spite of the undeniable fact that it somewhat is an excuse to maintain alive a hostility interior the subcontinent with distinctive gamers, each and each having an activity of its own! elementary to wager and so I depart it to the communicate board. approximately modern-day difficulty, the persons in charge are the state govt and the centre blended. the two had pampered the separatists for too long. Even the suitable ruling party had shared ability with undemanding secessionist outfit interior the state. the defense force and police are decrease than rigidity from appearing hard, being counseled via the two micro and macro rulers, to assuage rebels who does no longer settle for something wanting anarchy. they won't % police to seize stone pelters or the defense force to apply its gadget yet cajole the weapon weilding miscreants or face quotes of 'excesses'! harmless locals who only want a stable governance from somebody, the police who want a govt that could comprehend a thank you to handle a regulation and order equipment, the media that hanker for ''warm information stuff'' to excite the purchasers, the neighbour ever busy to push set off aspects interior a non violent terrain and shout 'wolf' while the triggers are being quelled.. and a govt that lighting fixtures fixtures candles on each area.. all are interior the recreation, to confound the confusion! different than the folk and the lots compelled police rigidity, no different participant is raring to have the matters 'solved' yet prefer to 'take care of' for their 'words'. They comprehend each and each problable ''answer'' has its proportion of extra intense impacts and ought to least brook a try!!! Insha Allah! hello Ram!

Answer 4

according to me if this matter will be solved neday whether in this deacde or the next one it would have two possibilties.
one- kashmir would be given to pakistan this would be if indian politicians get sick and tired of pakistan and get ready to give them some part.
second-there would be a big war to decide .india will win but it would be a great loss to mankind.

in all a third possibility would be that the issue gets over with the change in government in pakistan and the issue gets forgotten amidst the peace programs.


hope u like my opinion
lucky.

Answer 5

This about kashmir a wonderful place of earth but it is ruined now because of the misunderstanding between people,the person who wants kashmir form india must understand that people can live as they want as it is their land and by snatching it from one country to another doesnt make sense and doesnt bring peace to their people, i Prefer there is no use for fighting for land and more over that land is becoming obselete i prefer leave it as the people wanted and make it as it was once

Answer 6

as i understand, no plebiscite has taken place in kashmir. i think that it should be the people's opinion that should be taken into consideration. i know that this would not be that easy, as people might have been influenced by the militant activities. but then there is no ther way the problem could be resolved. in fact plebiscite should have happened much earlier. but it has not happened and situation then turned grave.

plebiscite seems to be the only answer.

Answer 7

Solution just 1 thing take over pakistan & get kashmir automatically ok.......

Answer 8

Dude, being a South Asian myself, my advise is to just leave it alone. PEACE is what is most important. India and Pakistan are currently going on the right path to peace, for now :s. Love thy enemy.

Answer 9

Kasmir citizens are to marry Punjab citizens...by doing this they will become husbands and wifes, brothers n sisters, in-laws..so no one will go after any thing, demanding and both sides will be exonerated from the uproar.

Answer 10

Fill the place with migrants from the rest of India and let them own property there. Keralites in particular will be suitable as they survive and do extremely well anywhere other than in their own state.