Do "hecklers" deserve to be reprimanded or punished?

Question

There have been a few occurrences in these last few months about Hecklers in relation to political opinions. Recently, a heckler was supposedly shoved into a chair by supporters after asking Sen. Allen about spitting on his wife. According to an article on cnn.com, the Senator has refused to scold his backers. At a Barbra Streisand concert, a heckler was reported to have supposedly said "Shut Up and Sing, this isn't a political event" in relation to skit involving Bush Impersonator, Steve Bridges and supposedly was told to F*** off by Barbra Streisand, herself. Do you think that "hecklers" deserve to face these kind of consequences? Do Hecklers have the right to behave this way in public? Your thoughts.

Answer 1

The term "heckle" can certainly be construed differently by different persons. In my opinion, your first example illustrates a gentleman asking a tough question to a political candidate. He certainly has the right to ask that question, and shouldn't have to endure an assault because of it. On the other side of the coin, however, is the allegation that this individual follows George Allen around regularly asking things that are not relevant to the campaign. In that scenario, he should be prohibited from interfering with the event. In your second example, the individual made a rude comment, and Barbra gave him a piece of her mind. The Bush impersonator is part of her show. Perhaps the individual wasn't aware of such, but maybe he should have known before he spent top dollar on Streisand tickets. Anyone that knows Barbra knows she is and has always been very liberal.

Answer 2

There is a point where hecklers can cross the line. The guy that spat on Sen. Allen's wife should be punished.

As for the guy at the Streisand concert, he was voicing his opinion (freedom of speech) and it was a one time thing. He didn't continually nag her. I wouldn't have done anything. Streisand should just sing because that's what people came to see.

Answer 3

Hecklers used to have the right to free speech as used to be guaranteed under our Constitution. Since the passing of the Patriot Act, many hecklers can now be arrested as possible terrorists or threats to the general public. Hecklers, under the Patriot Act, can and will be arrested. How about the Bush free speech zone which is nowhere near the event? Hecklers used to have a place in sociey. Hecklers often just express a different point of view. Now you can be arrested if your point of view or "heckling" is considered subversive. I think it takes alot of courage these days to be a heckler. Should we reprimand or punish hecklers...maybe...ask the government.

Answer 4

Okay. I'm a dad or mum. Whilst I believe in my opinion the punishment is far too extreme in a few elements it isnt in they all. Parents have a difficult time in this day and age treading the road among letting you might have a few freedom and retaining you reliable. The international is undoubtedly now not as reliable because it used to be whilst your father and mother had been younger. There are such a lot of men and women posing as any person else on the web that she is ordinarily certainly terrified that the individual she loves such a lot on the planet is dabbling in it. I believe a household dialogue could have greater acceptable the so known as crime. I believe going with out dinner for 3 days is obvious ridiculous and must now not be condoned. However - there need to be some thing on your behaviour or your manner that's ringing alarm bells on your mums head and while she will have over reacted on a grand scale a minimum of you'll be able to console your self with the truth that she cares sufficient. One day you're going to understand that almost all dad and mom do the matters they do out of affection and safety for people who are necessary to them and are the centre in their lives. Not in view that they're watching for some thing to moan at you approximately. You are without doubt a good cherished younger girl in a well household atmosphere. Instead of sulking approximately this ask to talk on your dad and mom approximately it - inform them that you simply fully grasp that they're seeking to defend you and you're thankful for that safety. However, downloading the image is in a few methods no exclusive to the posters we used to place up on our partitions of men and women comparable to David Cassidy and so on. Its simply the brand new means of doing it. Parents do regularly overlook that they had been younger as soon as - however at the complete they're simplest seeking to do whats exceptional for you. If you'll be able to exhibit through speakme rationally to them that you simply fully grasp and wouldnt do what they're accusing you of - they would good start to peer that you're certainly developing up and so they have got to permit the reins move just a bit bit. Dont knock them even though for loving you and short of to defend you. Youre going to be a dad or mum your self sooner or later - ordinarily - gain knowledge of the teachings now.