Who should shoulder the responsibility for Indian team's degeneration?

Question

The Coach, the captain, the selection committee.
Indian batting was an asset. What has happened to it? We are playing like novoices.

Answer 1

No one person is responsible coz it's a TEAM!!! Moreover it will do the team a great deal of good to sit down together and talk about the failure(s),identify and work on it instead of trying to find who is responsible.Please do not go the media way.They are being paid to criticise not you and me.WE MAKE THE MASS which is the majority and how we think makes a difference to everybody around us specially to THE TEAM.

Answer 2

Mainly Chappel and partly Dravid--the reason is that you don't have a steady batting order--just think about it---
a) opening---Sachin and Shewag or Sachin and Dravid----the problem arises her.
b)next to come in----Dravid or Pathan
c)no yuvaraj and Kaif in all sorts of trouble
d) dhoni seems to be firiing, but not fitring
e) no genuine bowler at all

Finally that's the team which India has---very sorry to say--its hopeless.
Even Bangladesh and Kenya have a standard batting order.

Answer 3

I think the players themselves shoud shoulder the responsibility.They are all collectively playing badly. They are ALL OUT OF FORM.God knows how long they are going to be out of form.They all need to be rested for a few matches, give a chance to some of the other players in ranji trophy.At the rate the indian team is playing,the novices might play better than them!

Answer 4

if someone could have taken the responsibility then this day would never had come. But our team just believes in giving excuses.
And when it comes to play against aussie, indian team just believes in miracles and just playing like helpless... that's we had seen from their body-language, even after a challenging total on the board.. Remember my friend, aussie is doing funny things when they know there is another chance even they lose that particular day (like they played against Windies), but they never do any funny things in do-or-die games...
And a big fact is that yesterday's lost from Aussie ended india's hopes of winning world cup next year.. Thats hard but fact..

Answer 5

All of them are the culprit...i can understand the fact that in a game one loses and one wins but this is not the case for us...our team lacks the determination... focus....sense of pride....passion for the game...!! There is only one reason why BCCI holds meeting...to make money..money and more money...what would they do with it, when the fans deteriorate....all of them lack honesty to their duty..atleast if they tried hard, it would show but no...they never try hard...i really wish everyone associated with this sport in India realizes that its not too late to come back to the right track before its tooooooo late!!

Answer 6

Greg Chappel

Answer 7

the MEDIA....especiallt the news channels....
when we play well....we are treated as heroes
when we dont.....we are criticised terribly.....
it is the media who is responsible for our failure....
cricket is a sport.....im sure these guyz are working hard.....winning and losing is a part of it !!! we indians no matter how much we may hate the team when we lose but we still continue to support our TEAM INDIA because we believe in our team and have a four-letter word called HOPE....we should support them no matter what....!!!! we can win !!! we have proved it in the past !!! we can do it again....are ppl succesfull everyday in their day-2-day life ... NO....but if we have the support of our loved ones, we work hard towards our goals in achieving it ... similarly our TEAM INDIA needs our love and support...!!!!!!

Answer 8

The players, as they are not showing any commitment and performing to their potential.

Answer 9

All the three

Answer 10

You