A friend told you that they were going to harm a person & told in confidence. But you know the other person...

Question

Would you reveal it to the other person, even though the person who is going to harm that individual is your best friend?

Answer 1

I would think it would be my "duty" to tell the other person that they may be in danger...However, often times people say they are going to do things when they are angry and usually don't mean that they are actually going to do something...Only you know what you should do in this situation, If the person making the "threat" has a temper and would really hurt someone, I would like to think that you would do the right thing? Good Luck!

Answer 2

If someone is in danger, you have a moral obligation to prevent harm by telling. How can a person be your "best friend" if they are the kind of person who goes around harming others? Think about that. How can you like a person who harms others? If you don't want to tell, then at the very least go to your best friend and tell him/her that harming others upsets you and you can't be friends if anything like that happens. But, if it were me, I'd warn the person about to be harmed, and if it is the type of harm that means bodily injury or death, I'd call the police and warn them.

Answer 3

New question. Why would you be friends with someone who threatens harm onto someone.
And to answer your question, you have a moral responsibility to yourself and the person who may be harmed. If you turn a blind eye you are just as responsible for anything your so called friend does. In my profession we have a policy called Duty to Warn. If we hear a threat and don't report it to our supervisor or the person who was threatened we can be held responsible if anything happens. So make a mature decision and warn the person of what your friend has planned.

Answer 4

I you should talk to your best friend and let him/her know that you feel obligated to warn the other person. Perhaps you can talk your best friend out of harming that other person and deal with whatever issue is between them in a more mature, less harmful way.

Answer 5

You are ethically, morally, and legally compelled to tell the potential victim, or someone who can warn/protect that person. Confidentiality does not extend to you being a party to what you know is wrong.
If you believe your friend is sincere, and not just venting or talking trash, then you should make your best effort to defuse the situation or warn the victim to be.

"All that is required for evil to succeed is for good men to do nothing."

Answer 6

Fellow Cutter here, properly, for one, as quickly as you're lowering when you consider which you're depressed then i counsel you communicate to a typical practitioner approximately it. until ultimately you are the type that's doing this by way of the indisputable certainty this is a sparkling form now, stop! What leads me to this is by way of the fact an exceedingly CUTTER/SELF-HARMER shouldn't in any respect tell actually all and sundry of their finished lifetime. until ultimately it develop into printed by way of twist of destiny or caught! it is a few intense corporation your in, I actual have been lowering thinking 10. My arm is slashed with wounds and scars, usual I awaken as depressing and ineffective as prevalent, then I turn to the in uncomplicated words want I extremely have left after being RAPED, ABUSED, missed and HURTED, a blade. I press deep indoors my wrist the region I see something crimson on the very end of the each and every and each consultation. on the comparable time as this is time, it loses satisfaction after which you bypass directly to SUICIDE. you realize you should no longer any quantity extra something left to stay for, you bypass out of your with the aid of kill your self. tablets, residences, poison, something. SO bypass forward, proceed to shrink returned. yet as quickly as you realize AT ONE ingredient THAT IT in uncomplicated words MAKES themes WORSE THAN you would be sturdy the region i'm NOW.... DEPRESSES AND SUICIDAL.

Answer 7

absolutly if you can prevent it then yes u need to reveal it . it is the right thing to do, if someone was planning on harming you wouldn't you be greatful to someone who told you when it comes to this kinda situation chosing the right thing is better than trying to be loyal to your friend this could be very serious so u need to act asap gl

Answer 8

Of course I would. It's wrong to harm anyone. It doesn't matter if it's a friend who wants to do it. You really need to get a new friend.

Answer 9

That's hard to say...maybe you can warn the person who's azz is going to get kicked that they should take an alternate route home, you don't have to give specifics...

Answer 10

Yes you are bound to report it both ethically and legally. You are presently in a conspiracy to assault, batter, and or possibly maim or kill another person. You are vulnerable to charged by knowing that. Get rid of the knowledge, by telling police, or else you remain liable.