Is Snape innocent?

Question

Snape killed Dumbledore coz he had too [unbreakable vow]
i think he's innocent, i'm sure he did that on dumbledore's orders..what do you think??

And should ginny really be with Harry? or is Cho a better match?

Answer 1

Asolutely. I am a firm believer that what happened was all part of the plan. And that Snape went back to Voldemort for protect Draco. And I do also believe that Snape will die in Bk7 saving either Harry or Draco.

But what so I know? I have lots of theories of Bk7.

I think Dumbledore will someway come back, and the same with Sirius. I don't think either he or is brother Regulus is dead. And the intials RAB are Regulus'. I think Nagini is a Horcrux and also that Luna knows the location of one of them.

I know Neville and Bella have to have some sort of showdown.

Harry has to go back to school, and Hogwarts will stay open because they need a new Defense Against the Dark Arts teacher.

This is only a few things of what I think will happen.

Answer 2

I don't think 'innocent' is the correct label. He's guilty of several things, such as treating Harry unfairly in Potions class and-- at one point or another-- being involved in Death Eater activity. He's not 'innocent,' but he's not 'evil,' either. He's on our side. He killed Dumbledore on Dumbledore's orders because Dumbledore believes that Snape is an important key to helping the Order and Harry defeat Voldemort, so important that he needs to continue convincing Voldemort that he's on his side, even if that means killing Dumbledore. Why he's so important, we don't know, but we know that Dumbledore trusts him. I think this editorial ( http://www.mugglenet.com/editorials/thenorthtower/nt42.shtml ) nails that argument perfectly. Snape often holds to his own interests, but in the end, he will have contributed the most to the good side.

And as for your question regarding Harry's love life, I believe that Ginny is way better for him than Cho. Ginny is a strong-willed, tough lady who will always stand by Harry's side. He needs this far more than a 'human hosepipe.'

Answer 3

We will just have to wait and see about Snape because he was working for both sides even thought he killed Dumbledore. Snape did hate Harry's father and his friends Sirius and Remus so I think that now that Dumbledore is gone that Snape will go after Harry for revenge on what James and his friends did to him when they were teenagers going to Hogwarts

Harry should be with Ginny because her brother Ron had said that he would rather that she be with Harry that any other guy because he could trust Harry. He should not be with Cho because Cho still has feelings for Cedric even though Cedric died in Harry Potter and The Goblet of Fire because of Wormtail doing what Voldemort has requested of him

Answer 4

It can go either way. I believe that he is innocent, Dumbledore knows of the unbreakable vow. So he and Snape must have had a plan if Dumbledore had to killed by Snape. At the end the table became surrounded in flame and became a white tomb, this signifies that Dumbldore still has magical power. Also it is a theory that Dumbledore has his own Horcrux, he did destroy the dark Wizard Grindelward (see chocolate frog, book 1). So yes i believe he is Innocent.

Answer 5

I hope Snape is innocent. I'd hate to think Dumbledore's trust was so terribly misplaced.

I prefer Ginny over Cho. Cho used Harry after Cedric's death. Ginny has loved Harry since the first time she saw him when she was 10 years old (before she even knew he was the "boy who lived").

Answer 6

I think he did do it on Dumbledore's orders. I don't think his character was likely to beg for his life. It seems more likely to me that he was begging Snape to go thru with it so he (Snape) wouldn't be discovered. I'm really hoping that there is some type of wizard reincarnation that will happen like in LOTR with Gandolf.

Ginny is totally a better match for Harry. She is a fighter just like Harry. I never really cared for Cho's character.

AND while we're on the subject, would Ron and Hermione just admit their feelings for each other and quit making each other miserable.

Answer 7

Yeah but that doesn't make him any better as a person. Maybe just a little sympathy should be given to him. (As sympathy given to Gollum from LOTR.. Gandalf says this to Frodo, that pity is should be given to him)

I thought is was weird at first that Harry and Ginny get together but it makes sense, they both survived and seen Voldemort together and that would give them the same purpose and sense to stop him.. Kind of cute if you think about it and say aaaawwww... (minus the gloomy things to come.)

Cho doesn't really cut it for Harry and neither would it work for the plot very well. She has not experienced much of the same things with Harry and being that she was with Cedric Diggory who died.. well.. that would be really awkward to talk about in a relationship.. and enough's said there... his death would be really hard to talk about... And Being that J.K. Rowling has got one book to go, there's no real reason to have a mending relationship to take up the entire book while there are more troublesome and foreboding events going on. Plus, Cho is not as close of a friend and she's definitely not on the same page as Harry's friends are, as far as knowing all their little experiences and adventures together.

Ginny on the other hand has some of the same traumatic exposure as Harry went through...though not its entirety.

Answer 8

No, I think Snape is guilty. He wanted to make the vow with malfoys mum.
No, Ginny shouldn't be with Harry. And Cho isn't any good either.

Answer 9

Ummmmmmmmmmmmmmmm,well,Snape is more like someone who follows orders to both the dark side,and the good side.Ginny is too young for Harry!Cho is way better!

Answer 10

Snape is as guilty is as Wesley Snipes is black

As for Harry, Cho is a whiny as h*** and if Ginny doesn't work out then theirs always Luna Lovegood