Josh Hartnett in The Black Dahlia?

Question

What did u think of Josh Hartnett in The Black Dahlia?
His perfomance was criticized and the movie got awful reviews. Personally, i think he was quite good in the movie. What do u reckon?

Answer 1

I didn't like Josh Hartnett, then I saw The Black Dahlia and I think he's a good actor, but his other roles before Brian dePalma's film were worse than this. He plays the role of Bucky Bleichert very well, as a young cop that discovers Black Dahlia Murder's truth. I think he should accept better scripts, 'cause than he will became a better actor. The Black Dahlia is a great film, if it was in black and white, I'd think it is from the 40's. Camera movements, cinematography and the argument are also fantastic. Hillary Swank's very good playing the role of Madeleine. At the moment, I'm reading the original novel by James Ellroy and it's pretty good. If you like the film, you should read the book.

Answer 2

Who would have suspected that the murder of the Black Dahlia would be an subplot in this movie. Of course, it would have to be -- because there was no actual plot. Key characters are introduced mid-film, allegiances are so convoluted and under-developed that one is left confused over the emotions effused by the characters and really, what is up with Josh Hartnett's hair? It's like a buffed-up Marty McFly is playing the lead - however, Crispin Glover actually has acting talent.

The acting is all over the place and there are some great comedic scenes. Unfortunately, these scenes were meant to be dramatic - such as an open-robed clad Kay (Scarlett Johanssen) slamming the door as Marty McFly a.k.a Bucky (Hartnett) longingly gazes up at her.

The editing was dreadful - I don't think anyone knew which direction the movie was to take or which story-line was important. It seems that more concentration was put into over-developing the film-noir appearance of the movie (every time someone was driving in the car, it was raining -- really? it rains that much in L.A.) and dear God, the lazy saxophone soundtrack. Two hours of relentlessly contrived music playing in the background - it was so cliche.

In short, this is the worst movie I have ever seen. I am so disappointed. I love murder mysteries and film noir. This film is a sad attempt at both. Hilary Swank, who usually picks her projects well, must not have read the screenplay before accepting her role in this film.

Answer 3

It was a good movie and for some reason people love to criticise such movies with talented young actors / actresses such as Josh H and Scarlett J. They make a good pair and the movie has a great poster lol Besides the guy has done a good job so don't care what people say , its your opinion that matters.

My personal Fav in the movie has to be Hilary Swank, such a great talent ( Million Dollar Baby ) .

Answer 4

definite, I agree. After seeing the action picture, I went and skim the e book to work out if it replaced into extra constructive. It replaced into. i imagine the project replaced into that they tried to cram 500 pages on tale right into a 2 hour action picture. in the technique, truly some stuff replaced into decrease out, and when you consider that they decrease it out, the tale did not make truly some sense. The e book is as large because the action picture is poor.

Answer 5

I thought he was good in that movie probably the best , Aaron eckhart wasnt bad either though. I loved Josh in Lucky Number slevin... it was awesome.

Answer 6

never heard of Josh Hartnell or The Black Dahlia...sorry

Answer 7

I knew the origin of the true story it's based on which was on discovery the other week. I was totally lost when I watched the film as it didn't sem to folow at all and seemed to go on forever! stil like al things you have to make your own mind up!

Answer 8

Don't know never watched it sorry

Answer 9

dont no