Would it be bad if Isreal was just given up?

Question

What would be so bad about just giving it up since problems will never cease?
Is it better to just keep killing and injuring, and getting killed or injured?
To never feel truly safe?

Would it be better to have the Jews return to Europe or America and perhaps deport the Muslims in Europe to Isreal?

Answer 1

This may clarify the issue for you.

If Hezbollah, Hamas, and other terror related parties were to disappear, the fighting would stop instantly. Israel would begin to reduce it's military, and the region would blossom economically, as Israel's 1.5+ million Moslems (yes, Islam is strong in Israel!) begin to help their fellows in surrounding nations.

If Israel were to disarm today, the terror groups would conquer tomorrow. Israel's population of 5 million Jews would be slaughtered, either by mass shootings, or by having their throats cut open (the traditional method of slaying a goat.)

Think about this, and decide which world is better for all.

Answer 2

I'm not a historian or a Jewish person, but the Jewish people (12 huge tribes) owned the land and lived on it in what's now Israel (and surrounding countries -- their empire was large) thousands of years before there even was a Mohammed prophet starting Islam or before a Jesus for Christians.

In the US and Canada (and Australia and NZ) pay restitution to the indiginous peoples / the people who lived on the land hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of years ago. The Indians and aboriginees are also given at least some of their traditional lands back. The Jewish people weren't given restitution. But they were "allowed" to have back a small part of the land that was theirs.

Muslims were given chunks of Israel after their complaining... Gaza strip, Muslim quarter in Jerusalem (there's a Christian quarter too and they didn't have to do that) for example. If they are law-abiding and non-violent, Muslims are welcome to live in Israel, worship there, enjoy the rights shared by their fellow Israelis. (Just because someone is an Israeli citizen doesn't mean they're Jewish just like because someone is Jewish doesn't automatically make them an Israeli).

There are dozens of Muslim-only countries. There is only one "Jewish" country. The Muslims can go anywhere they want, but they only want what other people have.

But when radical extremists using terror and violence break the laws, kill people, cross internationally recognized borders and kidnap people and hide behind religion to do it; when caught they claim to have rights under the Geneva Convention (the GC only applies to actual soldiers in a recognized military, which they're not) and yet somehow Israel and the Jews aren't supposed to blame them or protect themselves? Weird.

Jews weren't traditionally in Europe or America, so why should they be sent away there?

Look at wikipedia or other sites. The Muslims have been fighting with someone and fighting over something from day 1.

Watch Glenn Beck on CNN.

The Muslims want to rule the entire world. They want everyone to convert. The radial Muslims want to bring about armageddon so their missing holy man will return and burn all us infedels (un believers in Islam) into ashes and the faithful Muslims will rule the planet.

Learn about the president of Iran. Listen to the hate spewed by radical Muslims, including people in the US. Learn about the Crusades (Muslim against Christian wars) and the Ottoman Empire. Watch "Munich" which is a true story about Muslims slaughtering Israeli olympic athletes in Munich, Germany in the early 1970's.

I've never seen a Jew hijack airplanes. I've never seen a Jew fly airplanes into skyscrapers. I've never heard of Jews teaching their young children to hate Muslims and Christians and teaching them how to kill before they're seven. Judaism seems to be a religion of tolerance.

The Jewish religion and culture and people have been around since before the great pyramids in Egypt were built, and they're still going strong today. I think they must be doing something right. Christianity and Islam are still baby religions in comparison.

As for non-radical Muslims... do you ever hear anything about them? No? Exactly!
And do you hear about non-insane Christians? No? Exactly. But David Koresh and the branch Davidian and other "Christian" nutjobs sure make the news, don't they.

Answer 3

This problem has been going on since the time that the ancient Hebrews decided to settle in the land that was not theirs to begin with, and until fairness and justice is seriously considered by USA and Britain, who are totally responsible for the mess "THEY" have created in Palestine, The Muslims of the world over would not stop demanding the destruction of Israel. So, George, Tony and the Zionists of the world better accept, recognize and realize the seriousness of the matter and stop fighting the Muslims senselessly. Muslims did not spread allover the world because they were peace loving people. And let the rest of the world keep that in mind before it's too late for USA, Britain and Europe..

Answer 4

The state of Israel was created because Europe did not like the Jews . Mr.Cohen wrote the same thing too,He also wrote Making Israel in Arab land was a mistake.The reality that Israel is Anglo American Proxy in middle east.The real answer will be given after the oil is finished.

Answer 5

No, because that is their ancestral home. Also, Israel is the only bastion of Democracy in the entire Middle East. The Muslims are not going to stop just because Israel is given up. They want to take over the entire West, because that's what their religion teaches. We need Israel as an ally in the Middle East. As goes Israel goes the West.

Answer 6

It wouldn't be too much fun for Israel. Then again, the argument that ANY nation has a "right to exesit" is absurd. Any nation that cannot stand on its own belongs on the heap of discarded nations that have risen and fallen throughout history.

Answer 7

Great idea. What ever State you live in, we'll throw you and its citizens out and then give it back to the Native Americans.

Answer 8

that is a (french m.o.) typical liberal idea,to give something believing it will save you,maybe you should do a little history research,the Jews were there,before Christ(oops did i say Christ sorry liberals),but non the less,they were in Israel before Israel was even named,remember Christ (oops did i say Christ again) was born in Bethlehem.

Answer 9

its God's promised homeland to the promised people (the jews).
Give up? I'd rather be in the promised land.

Answer 10

its never gonna end as long as we have religious fanatics, jews believe israel belongs to themselves and muslims think that it belongs to themselves