is this a good trade?

Question

my friend will give me
M. Brunell
L. Fitzgerald
K. Jones
L. Tomlinson
for
C. Palmer
C. Portis
R. Johnson
and this is my team
QB C. Palmer
QB D. Carr
WR C. Chambers
WR L. Coles
WR J. Galloway
RB C. Portis
RB R. Johnson
TE J. Witten
W/R A. Randle El
K N. Rackers
DEF Baltimore
and this is my bn but for week 7 because they have bye week T. Heap
S. McNair
V. Young
D. Williams
Ro. Smith
L. White

Answer 1

I don't like the trade. Without Palmer you're weak at QB and Brunnell is no better than Carr. Fitzgerald is injured. The real question is what week do you play your friend's team- week 8? That's a bye week for both Jones and Brunell, so you're won't have either of them available, while he gets Palmer and Johnson to use against you...

Sure it's great to have LT and Fitzgerald, but I'd rather have a top flight combo like Palmer & Rudi than a crapshoot at the QB position.

Answer 2

Seriously I wouldn't do that trade for a number of reasons it would take away from you whole team....Brunell and Fitz won't even give you any points week 8 or longer for Fitz that's two wholes you have right there It takes away alot of depth that you have on your team Kevin Jones is alright but, it's not going to balance out Portis and Johnson together even with LT your just taking on alot of headaches doing it Kevin Jones is not automatic but, Portis and Johnson are LT is great great player but, what makes this trade poor for you is Fitz and Brunell's bye week you could lose a couple games because of it I would stick with what you have the season still has a long long way to go be patient I think you will regret it

Answer 3

Make the trade. 2 reasons:

1st - LT, he is the most versatile back in the game and he's the best fantasy player in the game. I know Portis and R. Johnson are good but with LT you are getting prob. about 12 more TD's, he may even throw one and he'll def. catch a few.

2nd - Youre getting 4 players for 3, and all 4 are at least good, some even stellar. I know Palmer is a good QB but Carr has been more impressive this season and there is no signs of letting up with him having some good receivers to throw to and the Texans having to play from behind a whole lot, plus they have a horrible running game which means Carr will be passing a whole lot.

K. Jones is an ok back but you also have D. Williams and you are getting LT who makes up for anyone. Brunell is old but he can still be good, especially as a fantasy backup. He has a good group of WR's/TE's/FB's/RB's to throw to.

If ur getting LT take it!!!

Answer 4

Wow. That's a monster trade. I've never seen a trade in my league with anywhere near that kind of star power. Getting L.T. is enormously huge, but giving up Palmer and Rudi is just as big. I would not take the trade because you will be hurting yourself at QB (Palmer will only get better, Brunell will never get any better).

Still, it's hard not to be tempted by Tomlinson.

Answer 5

Yes its a good Trade, You are getting LT 4 tds last week leads the league in tds and his buy wk is over, Fitz will be back and Brunell has some great wks so yes its a great trade. Tomlinson makes this hole trade awsome...

Answer 6

they're attempting to bypass Larry Hughes, yet he has distinctive years left on the deal. If the Nets somewhat offered Bobby Simmons, they have been stupid to no longer take it, as a results of fact he has a shorter deal. i do no longer think of he could be moved. Noah and Thomas will generate average interest, Thomas extra beneficial than Noah, yet they could't get something significant back for them. The movable products are Gooden and Hinrich and that they could somewhat get some value for the two or the two a form of fellows. they want a huge guy with submit skills badly. The Kings have had their eye on Gooden for some years now, yet with the emergence of Jason Thompson, i do no longer think of that they had commerce Brad Miller for Gooden now.

Answer 7

i would do this trade because l.t. is so valuable putting up huge numbers and fitzgerald will come back strong

Answer 8

NO! Grandpa M.Brunell can not make it through a whole season.

Answer 9

I don't know. But I once got a pushbike for my wife. Best swap I ever done!

Answer 10

ANY TIME YOU CAN GET L.T. DO IT HE IS A FLAT OUT STUD. IS CARR OR A SMITH AVAIL THEY BOTH PUT UP GOOD FANTASY #'S