Would you offer this trade?

Question

I have 6 guys on bye this week; including 3 RB's (T Jones, T Henry and F Gore). I have my RB's filled though already with LJ, Westbrook and M Barber III.
I am considering offering Gore for Fred Taylor; not just for this week (putting Taylor in for Barber); but looking ahead at the defensive schedules Taylor seems to have a cake walk compared to Gore.
Would you offer Gore for Taylor? Or is Gore worth more than that?

Answer 1

That would be a really bad trade. Not only do you lose a top RB, but you gain an injury prone time-sharing RB in Taylor. Gore is worth a 1st or 2nd round fantasy pick. Taylor is not.

Answer 2

I would probably wait until the end of this weekend just to see if Taylor gets hurt (which he is known to do about this time). Gore is not a bad option, he's really all the 49ers have with Alex Smith still struggling. But I would really wait til the end of the weekend then take another look at it.

Answer 3

Gore is better than Taylor because Taylor always gets injured.. I would just take a loss this week unless of course your opponent has more problems with the bye week

Answer 4

I would do it. Taylor has put up better numbers more times than Gore. Jaguars have a better team than the 49ers anyway.

Answer 5

Good trade but Gore is No1 in SF and Taylor splits time. I'd trade Gore but i'd think about it good first.

Answer 6

"Fragile" Fred...

Gore is still a top player with a couple bad weeks... Jones Drew I think will continue to get more playing time... it looks like a bad trade all around

Answer 7

ummm I'd probly do that but...

I like Dunn I'd try for him if I were you