Is the NFL hurting the game by overly protecting the QB?

Question

Or is the game hurt by its star QB's getting hurt?

Answer 1

I say yes . Its a contact sport . If you can't take the hit , get the hell out . Just my opinion .

Answer 2

First, it quite is not a clean rule. it is a clean interpretation of an contemporary rule. you could desire to no longer hit the QB under the knees or above the shoulders in the pocket besides. The refs have been letting it pass if the defender were blocked to the floor. the hot interpretation is that in case you're blocked into the passer, that continues to be ok. although, as quickly as your momentum has been stopped, you won't be able to restart it and touch the passer under the knees. Does this make experience? of direction. I endure in strategies decrease back in the 1970's and 1980's whilst many of the beginning QB's ignored a minimum of one start up a 12 months using break. no person needs their team's shot on the playoffs using on the shoulders of the 2nd or third string QB. the subject is that once he's putting as much as pass he's a sitting duck whose ft are firmly planted in the turf so as that a fulfillment under the knee has extra of a great gamble of doing considerable injury than a runner being tackled under the knee. There additionally are particular protections given to pass receivers, kick receivers, kickers, punters, and holders yet you do no longer pay attention human beings wanting to place Devin Hester in a gown, do you?

Answer 3

I agree that QBs need to be protected. But shouldn't that be up to the offensive line? A defenseman can't even put a finger on a QB lately without getting a penalty called on him. It's ridiculous! Quarterbacks are football players, not porcelain dolls!! I think there should be some extra protection for a QB but I think they've gone above and beyond. Football is a physical sport. Period.

Answer 4

Absolutely, these guys are football players for crying out loud, not kickers. There are definitely some special rules that need to be set aside to protect these guys, they are in a vulnerable position, but the league has clearly taken it too far. The whole game is drained of intensity due to the rules protecting the quarterback (do not even get me started on rules protecting WRs). It's turning into pitch and catch out there, the next step is replacing the NFL with the National Flag Football League.

Answer 5

Absolutely not. There are less than 32 guys in the US who can productively lead an NFL team's offense and make them competitive. Without these guys, the quality of the sport is completely watered down and the talent of the other 10 guys goes to waste. Every time a starting QB is injured, playoff hopes are more than likely crushed for that team, resulting in playoff competition of simply whoever remains unhurt for the season. That isn't competition!

If you want to see 3-0 games, watch soccer.

Answer 6

a QB who plays in the NFL,or college for that matter,knows what they are getting into.they know what to expect.they are there as a player.therefor ought to be treated as one of the players.if things are so bad why not protect the recievers and backs the same as the QB?

Answer 7

the NFL is hurting the game. QBs also deserve less credit for wins (but also less blame for losses). We should analyze all position and see who's fault it really was.

Answer 8

Yes. Ruffing the passer= a terrible rule, and the quickest way to get Peyton Manning a SB win!

Answer 9

Yes and the plumber does protect the health of the nation. Nice picture.

Answer 10

no, come on.

if you didn't have a roughing the passer rule you would have cheap hits on the QB every single play. I would much rather see our good QBs make plays then sit on the sideline with injured ribs.

because of these rules, it just makes the sack that much sweeter when it's done right

go bears...

Answer 11

yes, they are protecting him way too much, lets go back to the good old days when turkey Jones of the Browns picked up Terry Bradshaw of the steelers and dumped him on his head and never got a penalty.