Who are the most underrated and overrated players in the NFL?

Question

Overrated:
Daunte Culpepper
Corey Dillon
Randy Moss

Underrated:
Tiki Barber
Marvin Harrison
Drew Brees

Answer 1

Overrated:
1.m.vick-atl.
2.c. johnson-cin.
3.R. Williams-det.
4.s.moss-wash.
5.K. Johnson-car.
6 C. Simms-tampa.
7.k.winslow-clev.
8.D. Bledsoe-dal.
9.J. Plummer-denv.
10.L. Jordan-raid.
11.LaVar Arrington -gaints
Underrated:
1.r .johnson-cin.
2.w.dunn-atl
3.E. James.ariz.
4.Drew Brees-nor.
5.Mario Williams-houst.
6.B. Leftwich-jax.
7.W. Parker-pitt.
8.R. Grossman chica.
9.Daunte Culpepper-mia.
10.Roy Williams -dal.
11.T.J. Houshmandzadeh-cin.

Answer 2

Overrated: Larry Johnson- one good season does not make a great back, I can't believe how many people rate this guy up there with LT or Barber.

Underrated: Well, first of all, none of your picks are underrated, everyone knows who they are, and everyone knows they are good. My pick would be Jamal Williams. He's the best Nose Tackle in the league, has been for a few years now, but how many people had heard of him before last Sunday? Or even now? Not many. He is the heart and soul of the Chargers defense, not Merriman.

Answer 3

Overrated- Willis McGahee, Drew Bledsoe, Daunte Culpepper
Underrated- JP Losman

Answer 4

overrated (even though i like the first one)

vick-he doesn't pass he just runs. until he learns how to do the passing game on a daily basis they ain't going no where..certainly not to a superbowl any time soon.

dwight freeny....come on now guy has one so so season and then suddenly he's a star..lol. how's he looking this year mike ditka lol

eli manning. people tend to forget a certain barber carries all the load there.

larry jonshon

underrated.

barber for sure (harrison? and brees? are you serious? those guys aren't underrated)

cincy's back-rudy-guy is a stud and no one know's it.

the whole saints team.

i was yelling this last year and this year. the saints WEREN'T AND AREN'T A BAD TEAM but espn insists its mircales when they win..come on now-they had a disaster last year had their best player go down-and before all that they were STILL a pretty good team. they got soooooo lucky they got bush and the position in the draft they had..matter of factly its almost not fair. even though they didn't do it on purpose-that disaster and injury helped an already good team get a great position in a draft loaded with play makers and studs. they lucked in big time.

reminds me of the spurs when they got duncan-had one of the best if not the best center in b ball with robinson-then he goes down..elliot get cancer-they both meant so much to a DECENT TEAM playoff team-then they go down-and the spurs get top pick and stud like duncan to go along with those two who were bascially just sitting out a year

down right not fair.

Answer 5

I DEFINITELY agree with Tiki being underrated!! He's way better than most of the RB's out there getting more attention than him.

Most overrated.....I think Culpepper this year has pretty much ruined his rep, and Randy Moss did that when he went to Oakland. I do agree that Corey Dillon is overrated...he's a good RB but not as good as he gets credit for.

Answer 6

Hopefully the rest of the NFL is not seeing Dillon as a top-tier back anymore. He has a lot of mileage on his legs, but he does have what many lack - a Super Bowl ring.

Answer 7

underrated...maroney from patriots kyle orton of the bears plaxico burress or sumthin for the giants eli mannning jullius jones of dallas patrick kerney hyped up reggie bush phillip rivers....i hate him tony romo terrel owens Donavan McNabb

Answer 8

Craig Terrill is under rated. look out for him to show his worth to seattle.

as a matter of fact. the whole deffefensive line is under rated.