Who do you think is the Better Quarterback, Eli Manning or Michael Vick? Because honestly, i think its eli Manning and its not even close! Vick is a great athlete great arm, great feet and legs, but he is so not a QB its ridiculous.
2006-10-13 13:05:56 · 8 answers · asked by Anonymous in Sports ➔ Football (American)
ifyuscargotochurc's,
they arent MY Giants. Im a Jet fan, and yes its true. Who admits to being a jet fan if they arent lol. But i like players on the Giants, and NOT particullarly ELi, i didnt like how he got himself traded to the Giants, by basically extorting the Chargers into trading him. But the simple fact of the matter is Eli is leap and BOUNDS a better QB than Vick, and by the time Eli is done playing people may laugh at you if you put Vick in same sentence as him. Vick is a WR playing Quarterback. For a long time i thought Vick was like Donovan Mcnabb (who by the way is ALSO a much better QB than vick), i thought Vick, like Donovan, woul realize he cant run all the time, to save himself he hasta run to avoid pass rush and find open targets to throw to, but clearly Vick, cannot throw the ball with ANY consistency and even he knows it, so he runs. Eli has 1200yrd passing, 9TDs, a 97.1 QB rtng, all put him in upper tier of nfl QBs. Vick has 580yrds, 3TD, 68QB rtng...nuff said
2006-10-13 13:36:46 · update #1
hmm...Totally different games. Eli is traditional, Vick isn't. If you had either one, you change your play calls dramatically.
I would take either one. If I got Vick, I'd have to roll out and bootleg more. Eli and I could run standard stuff, but no rollouts or bootlegs.
To your point though, no team (except Dallas with Roger Staubach) has won the big one (in the pro's) with a mostly running QB. Even in the old days when QB's only threw 10-15 times a game, the Super Bowl QB's (except Staubach) has been strictly a passer.
2006-10-13 13:15:27 · answer #1 · answered by cantthinkofanygoodnames 3 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Michael Vick is the better athlete, Eli is the better QB. Vick doesn't have the accuracy or the vision to be a great passer, he'd make one hell of a RB or a WR though.
As a Charger's fan, I'd just like to note that although Eli did cry like a wussie when the Chargers drafted him, we got Rivers and eventually Merriman out of the deal, so it turned out good for us.
2006-10-13 13:15:00 · answer #2 · answered by Anonymous · 0⤊ 0⤋
Vick is a better scrambler and, Eli, is better in the pocket. Vick scrambles out of neccesity, Eli doesnt have to, there are other players on the team. the GIANTS will win as, they did the last time. keep one guy at the line to deal with Vick also, look for Tiki Barber to get His usual hundred yards.
2006-10-13 13:34:42 · answer #3 · answered by ny21tb 7 · 0⤊ 0⤋
yea, you know Eli comes from a family of good QB's. Vick is the better athlete, can scramble in the pocket and pick up yardage, but mentally, Eli is a true MANNING!
2006-10-13 13:39:35 · answer #4 · answered by baybeegrl5 4 · 0⤊ 0⤋
yes you might be right . but your see the better ball player out there come Sunday when Vick and the falcon beat your giants . Vick do his thing and he don't try to imitate any other QB in football all he know is the falcons are winning ball game .go dirty birds
2006-10-13 13:10:44 · answer #5 · answered by ? 6 · 0⤊ 0⤋
michael vick is awesome if he can stay healthy
2006-10-13 13:11:47 · answer #6 · answered by emilymichelle 1 · 0⤊ 0⤋
Manning will get you more fantasy points.
And that's all that's important to me. :-)
2006-10-13 13:29:09 · answer #7 · answered by ratboy 7 · 0⤊ 0⤋
sure
2006-10-13 13:06:57 · answer #8 · answered by balay_idiot 2 · 0⤊ 1⤋