In my keeper league, should I keep Roy Halladay or Alex Rios?

Question

We're allowed to keep four. My other 3 are Alfonso Soriano, Carlos Beltran, and Garrett Atkins.

Answer 1

i can see your concerns about halladay. each year it seems he has just one more injury that makes him miss a few more starts. obviously as age comes-so do more injuries.

but lets not kid ourselve. rios is an up an coming stud-and i predict will have a huuuuuuge break out season next year..if and oooonly if...the jays get their shi.t right and START THE GUY instead of platooning him with those 2 other scrubs (i still don't that)-or if he's traded and plays every day.

but with that said.

YOU MUST KEEP HALLADAY.

Answer 2

Halladay is occasionaly an "injury-prone" player but he has one of the best stuff in baseball, so I would keep him for now. Alex Rios finally envision to be the OF that Toronto wanted out of this kid since they drafted him, but how long is he going to be the team's leadoff hitter considering his track record (he made a DL appereance this season that might have plague his breakout season), so I wouldn't count for Rios one good season (remember Adrian Beltre, Mark Prior, and Kerry Wood?). Otherwise, you have a good crop of keepers and their bound to be big trade baits, considering that Soriano is a FA, Beltran is not fully healthy despite a comeback season, and Atkins is living on borrowed times on Coors Field, so you might want to consider that when doing keepers.

Answer 3

I won my league this year with mediocre picthing. If I had one true ace on my team, I would've really blown the league away. Definitely keep Hallady b/c he's always a Cy Young candidate every year (much like a Santana or Carpenter). Getting good starting picthing is hard to find.

Answer 4

I won my league this year with good pitching. Hold on to Roy Halladay.

Answer 5

youre DUMB if you dont keep halladay