Does Nazi genocide justify zionist massacre of Palestinians?

Question

No offense, Just to gather the simple facts about racial discrimination.

Answer 1

Of course not.Nothing justifies murder...And it's really sad that the people who are still complaining about what the Nazis did to them learned absolutely nothing from it... and are doing the same thing to the Palestinians...

Answer 2

Reading the answers so far, Pirashkee, seems like the same stuff that attempted to answer your earlier question about Israel and why the US vetoes UN missions to explore the treatment of Palestinians, supported by most nations. (Close US allies abstained on these votes).
The question is criticised strongly by almost all the answers so far (including the inevitable steroidal response we are used to from some in the US now : bomb the b*****s!) .
The paranoidal notion that some Bush supporters have is that the Muslim world is bent on destroying the US and Israel. It is not.
Yes , I know there are extremists who do.
Israel has become a wedge driven into the side of the Arab world, and is now a US tool to ensure that the Arab world stays in fear and preferably divided. Anyway that fact and the supply of bombs for Lebanon etc is not news (unless you watch Fox, that is).
It is perfectly reasonable to link the genocide of the Palestinians by Israelis to the genocide by the the Nazis of the Jews, not because the scale and evil are similar necessarily but it draws attention to some important points.
Firstly, the killing of millions of Jews by the Nazis in WW2 was disgusting. Committed by a madman and enabled by his people makes it one of the most horrifying pieces of behaviour in history- and there have been many. However you have to ask the question, how is it that the Israelis have brutalised this group the Palestinians, also like the Israelis deprived of their homeland. The most evil aspect of this (and I will not list the murders, tortures, stealing of land, prevention of building wells, denial of any freedom of movement, tanks over homes and neighbours houses, missile attacks on targetted "terrorists", closing of universities) is the duration of this evil. Whilst Hitler had a year or two of power and destroyed many lives, the Israelis have pursued this criminal behaviour for years since 1967. This is a democracy committing these murders and organised killings. Now, I hear some people exclaim oh but they have killed some Israelis (just count up the numbers) and they have threatened the Israelis (with what?) and they have carried out suicide bombings they are terrorists! Let me say that if you put people to the wall and they have no way out-no future- no future for their families-no future for their children- no future for work, for travel for anything then strapping a bomb on yourself and getting courage from your peers to do so is probably what we might do in a similar hopeless position. Who knows?
. You might conclude that the Israelis are in many ways worse than the Nazis, in the extent to which they have destroyed a people's life and well being completely!
It is hardly surprising that other Arabs take a very poor view of the ways in which Israel has behaved and the way the US has supported this. I believe that the twin towers in Manhatten collapse was a payback partly by Arabs for Palestinian struggle, and partly (as seen by the nationality of the pilots) anger from Saudis for the "violation" of Arab land to help kill other Arabs. But that is specualtion. The torture and abuse by Israelis of Palestinians is not.
What is interesting, I think, is that the holocaust has become a sort of industry-the world, especially Europe, and more particularly the Germans, are afraid to touch the subject. As soon as any word of criticism arises of Israel or the Jews, the Jewish networks race into action to defend it self and to accuse any accusers of racism, anti semitism and so on.
So the question does raise a link which is important. Is it in fact that the World feels so guilty about what happened to Jews that it allows the Palestinians to be brutalised, made homeless, prisoners in their own remaining patches of dry land? The Jews are able to give a good account of themselves in English, have good media skills and know how to play the game of suffering. (a gas mask on CNN News in the TV studio in Tel Aviv at prime time during the first Gulf War was worth a million words!) But the Palestinians, how well do they come over as suffering? They do not speak English-they are not likely to be interviewed in the street by a Jewish or US TV crew to tell their story- they are already destroyed by 40 years of imprisonment and futile struggle and all their cries have fallen on deaf ears worldwide. If you were in that position what would you do? Impossible to imagine bringing up a family in this hell hole. Sure the leadership has been poor and the poor communication has not helped, but the fact remains that the World has stood by and let this fester!
The answers I see in this site and attempts to respond to the question are often full of venom and have a short memory of history.
Oh, and the answer to your question:- no - Nazi genocide does not justify what the Zionists are doing and have done for 40 years to Palestinians For those who answered in a hostile way before and seem to feel passionately about this subject I suggest you go to
Israeli-Palestinian ProCon.org I think this will help you understand what is a very complex subject, and makes people very short sighted and hot. We need cool heads to resolve this, and a settlerment HAS to be imposed in my view as the combatants cannot now see clearly..(For the record I am not Jewish, and I am not Arab, and I have worked in both Israel and Palestine. )

Answer 3

We supported when British implanted Israel in Middle East over looking the first majority of Muslim & Christian over Jewish immigrant in the midst of last century not in 14 century that we can claim that we were unaware of democracy and it requirements of respecting majority votes. Muslim 87% Christian 10% Jews 11%. Surely poor Jewish victim of holocaust needed refugee but they too needed psychological consoling and a crash lesson to remember that Palestinian are host before becoming occupying forces.

Jews were and are smart it's only the impact of Holocaust that they become too sentimental (which is justified) against oppressor (Which is this case no longer exist anymore) since West is all/mostly cultured now.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/timeline_of...
537 BCE King Cyrus the Great allows the Israelites.

1187 Saladin captures Jerusalem from Crusaders, allows Jewish settlement.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/history_of_...

In 1517, it was taken over by the Ottoman Empire and enjoyed a period of renewal and peace under Suleiman the Magnificent - including the rebuilding of magnificent walls of what is now known as the Old City. The rule of Suleiman and the following Ottoman Sultans brought an age of "religious peace"; Jew, Christian and Muslim enjoyed the freedom of religion the Ottomans granted them and..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/golden_age_...

The Golden age of Jewish culture in the Iberian Peninsula/SPAIN, also known as the Golden Age of Arab or Moorish Rule in Iberia, refers to a period of history during the Muslim rule of the Iberian Peninsula (the Roman and Visigothic Hispania) in which Jews were generally accepted in society and Jewish religious, cultural, and economic life blossomed.

Answer 4

First, you're able to be able to desire to stipulate what a Zionist is.The premises on which you began the query is incorrect: Israel is work out its precise to maintain itself, and it occurs now can look after itself plenty extra effectual they did interior the forties. The mere fact of the PLO demands for the anhilation of the state of Israel. i don't be attentive to the area are you from, by if the human beings (i'm Canadian) ought to declare that approximately Canada, Canada ought to somewhat kicked their butts as much as we are in a position to. that i'm in a position to guarantee you. What do you assume from persons that suffered what they did interior the palms of each and every and each individual (Islam, Catholics, Protestants, and so on)? Beside, the same Palestinians - on a similar time as in Jordania - tried to assessinate King Hussein and function been kicked out of there. Palestinians on the on the spot are actually not from Israel, yet from Jordania. optimal of those living there on the time of 40 8 the area Jordanians. the full land grew to develop into into interior the palms of Jordania, who did no longer pick to attempt against for it. They knew why. 2d, no count number while you're Jewish (religiously talking) or Christian, then you definitely could desire to exclude Yeshua (Christian) and each and all of the Prophets (being Jewish) for the two have been easily Zionist. In my own understand-how, people who've been TAKEN in 70 advert by the Romans - FORCEFULLY - have each and all of the the appropriate option to have their descendants, coming to the section their ancestors have been removed from, Jerusalem. 0.33 and intensely final, you're in a position to could desire to cut up Wind from the Air, for the rationalization which you will no longer have the skill to be a Jew different than you're a Zionist (by definition). the only place in which you will understand the removal (like Amadinajad desires, and Hitler tried) of the country of Israel (approved by the UN in 1948) is which you do no longer pick NEITHER what you call Zionists nor Jews, as a results of fact separate them the two is like putting apart the air from the wind.

Answer 5

One wrong does not justify another. That is why Gandhi preached tolerance to the Hindus, as against the Muslims, when the latter indulged in acts of arson and killing. If reprisal becomes the state and individual policy, then we will go back to animal stage in our civilization. Revenge is mine, so said the Lord in the Bible.

Answer 6

No, that's why Palestinians still exist. Your hatred march is perpetuating an unnecessary war. When your kind stops calling for America and Israel's destruction then we can have peace. Until then keep your head between your knees it's going to be a bumpy ride for you.

Answer 7

I think Israel is actually too soft on them. If it were up to me, I would order military forces to seize palestinian settlements, and and throw those bums into Jordan. This would be followed by an all-out assault on Syria. Iranian intervention would be met by swift, and decisive tactical nuclear strikes on their cities and military installations. I'm bloody tired of pinko cowards apologising for what those fanatical, inhuman roaches do. Wake up you morons; they want us all dead!!

Answer 8

NO.

You know people were asking the same question 30 years ago, even Jewish people. So, what has been done to improve the situation?

Answer 9

When did the palistinians become jewish? Racism is just in the question itself, if you meant it as you say to gather facts there are more tactful ways to go about it.....

Answer 10

nothing justifies killing just think if you had all the resources at hand except to kill to solve a problem can it be done? of course and we do.