To Trade or not to trade?

Question

I will be giving him Fitzgerald and M Jones Drew for Berrian and Alexander. He is critical because of the Madden Curse. I don't like my matchups at WR this week and thought Berrian would be a nice addition, not to mention Alexander is expected back soon.
My RB are McGahee, Jackson, Cadilac and De williams (Hurt)
My WR are Cotchery, Toomer and Horn
[ Jennings and Re Williams (bye)]
What do you guys think?

Answer 1

Hmm...Fitz is hurt and last week's game was a fluke for drew i think (even though i started him), berrian's becoming a star and alexander won't get points this season(also on my team). Your WR lineup looks good right now...I guess I'd say keep drew, and try to get someone else for fitz later.

Answer 2

definetly do that shaun alexander will still despite the injury be in the top 10 rbs, drew only gets about 5 carries a game, fitz is out for about 4 games and right now the way rex is playing berrian is better so u are getting the upper hand of the trade here

Answer 3

Let's break this trade down:

M. Jones Drew and Berrian are equal value. So the trade comes down to Larry Fizgerald vs Shaun Alexander. Larry is out 2-5 weeks, so I would do the deal. Make sure the owner knows that Fizgerald is hurt though.

Answer 4

I'd do that. Berrian is doing great and Alexander has to come to his own. Fitzgerald was hurt last game, coming out of the game for some injury, Alexander is hurt also.

Answer 5

excellent trade, alexander wont do what he did last year, but he'll come back strong, and berrian is on a tear and has a relatively soft schedule. fitz is out for 4-6, and drew is still splitting carries.great deal!

Answer 6

would definitely do that trade because alexander has recovered from his injury and bernard berrian is doing awesome right now because of rex grossman throwing to him and fitzgerald is out for 2-5 games so do it

Answer 7

Fair trade.