If you saw a Parent slap, punch, or any other type of abuse to their child in public?

Question

What would you do?....Would you say something?....Come between the Parent & Child?....or just walk away like you saw/heard nothing?

I would (& have) say something...I have even gone as far as stopping a woman's hand just as she was going to slap her 2 yr old across the face for crying....

Answer 1

Many children in our day and age have learned from TV and other sources that parents cannot be displinary in public. So they 'the kids' take advantage of that fact. When my daughter was 5, and threw a fit at the check stand because she couldn't have a candy displayed at the counter, I slapped her little butt and said 'NO' then she looked at the cashier lady for sympathy. I said to her, 'the cashier' "No Sale" "I'll be back for the groceries" I gave her a 100 dollar bill to save my basket. I took my 5 year old daughter outside and told her if she ever threw a fit in a public place again, I'd never take her anywhere with me again. I took her home, got a babysitter, and went back to the store alone, and retrieved my groceries. I made my 5 year old daughter bring all the groceries in to the house and put them away, know in herself, that I was too embarrassed to take her back to the store. After that, she was a perfect angel everywhere, and anywhere I took her with me. Now she's 25 years old, and calls me for advice with her 3 y/o daughter, my granddaughter. LOL. I did it out of love, not power, that's the difference, I think.

Answer 2

I think I would watch carefully to see how the discipline is being handled and then would act accordingly.

I would not physically intervene unless I thought there was a good possibility the child would be hurt. I would likely speak to the parent in any case.

If I felt the parents were handling the discipline appropriately I would not intervene.

You said slap, punch or any other type of abuse. Abuse is relative. I would say any slapping or punching would be abuse, but spanking might not be if it were handled properly.

Have you noticed how many parents take their small children shopping with them at midnight or later at Walmart type stores? I think that's abuse, but I'm not sure what to do about it.

Answer 3

I would too and I commend you. I think that as a society it is our duty to remember that it "takes a village to raise a child". We must learn to stop looking the other way! It is because of our "mind your own business" mentality that so many kids are abused too long. They become so damaged that they are sometimes dangerous.
Look at the life of some serial killers. What if someone had intervened on their behalf when they were being so abused they became broken? They might never have lost their humanity the way they did.

Answer 4

you may study Kahil Gibrans comments on little ones Sara. little ones are separate spirits as all of us are.mom and dad foolishly think of that their newborn is their sources and a version of ,"little ME,".they have them because of the fact they are concept is be frutful and multiply or the blessing of a courting is a newborn or little ones. They then deliver that youngster right into a international have been the skill is of their palms besides the indisputable fact that the skill is interior the palms of the controllers of societies that see human beings and little ones as purchasers and commodities. they have little ones as prestige symbols then pass away them to pursue careers and have interaction of their person early existence of accumulating materialist aims which in turn they inflict on the youngster. All a newborn needs is the affection and presence of their mom and dad. some do get this jointly as others get something diverse. The mendacity field interior the lounge the television is the hot babysitter and now it quite is the telephone or laptop. how are you able to be bored with loving your newborn? how are you able to be pissed off with your newborn until eventually your interest is distracted away out of your newborn? it isn't any ask your self our toddlers improve to despise our ideals and ideology because of the fact we've enable them to down badly by believing interior the fake ideals capitalist secularist materialist societies inflict on all human beings. We for the 1st time are a technology without suggestions left to pass in direction of a fashion forward for altruistic concept and making plans for our toddlers and their little ones. Harming a newborn in any way is abuse. A merciless assertion can ingure a newborn yet enable us to no longer overlook our technology and those formerly us have been suggested in a type of abuse weren't they. how a lot of human beings have been bodily abused,Spare the rod and injury the youngster,the place does that sit down with the classes of Jesus to go through the toddlers to return unto me. everybody who spoke back you asserting it does no long term harm are already broken to the factor of denial and are inhabited by a recommend spirit. our toddlers quickly will upward push up against us if we don't show them love by changing the international for them.

Answer 5

I saw that once but I got too scared that she gonna punch me as well ... :( ...so I just gave her bad look

Well done for for stopping that woman slapping her child

Answer 6

I would try befriend her try help her get control see how you can be a friend help her by asking her IF THERE POSSIBLE WAY YOU COULD BECOME FRIENDS ... I TRY AND SMILE AT THE CHILD GET THE CHILD TO BEHAVE BY SAYING SOMETHING OFF THE WALL LIKE OPPS AND SAY IT TOUG BEING A MOM AND SMILE HOPE THAT OPEN HER HEART ... YOU NEVER KNOW BUT YOU TRIED THAT HUMAN CAUSE TO HELP HER GET CONTROL OVER HER SITUTION CHILDREN NEED LOVE NOT ABUSE OR TIRE MOM ...JUST MAKE IT SIMPLE CARE THAT ALL ONE CAN DO...

Answer 7

If it's a normal spanking then I wouldn't do anything at all. If it was truly abusive I would use my cellphone and call 911.

Answer 8

it can be hard to interveen but would depend on the age of the child and how the parent was responding