Should people be "blamed" for mental problems?

Question

Since we "blame" people for being sociopaths, does it make logical sense to "blame" people for being scizos or retarded? After all, mental problems tie in with your psyche, and can become a part of your "character". Do we need to differentiate from disabling disorders and personality disorders?

I'm playing Devil's Advocate big time here, but I thought this would be an interesting question.

Answer 1

no

Answer 2

sociopaths just get "blamed" because they do severe harm to other people, and have morals and actions that deviate from what's considered "normal" (although nothing is really normal). your whole being is THE COMBINATION OF genetics + environment, so i think it's unfair to blame anybody in the creation of mental disorders in another person, because you can't really test to see if the person's mental disorders were totally a cause of someone else's actions or totally a cause of genetics.

i'm also confused about your terms of disabling disorders and personality disorders, because in my mind they are both the same - personality disorders like schizophrenia can be very disabling.

Answer 3

The difference between insane and sane is simple, dopes the person understand the consequences of his actions. A sociopath does, but doesn't care. A shizo or retard might not.

Answer 4

People should not be blamed for mental problems. It all depends on what level of personal responsibility their illness allows. If someone harms another, but is not capable of knowing that their actions would lead to harm, then the ill one is not to blame. If they are capable of assessing the harm factor, and blame their actions on the illness, then they should be blamed.

Answer 5

No, i won't say I extremely have been feeling that way. in spite of if from this question it sounds as though that i'm between the few who have not had an identity disaster of a few variety. i did not comprehend it became that uncomplicated a situation. besides, i like the poem, Goldfish. to respond to your actual question, confident, I do act like particular characters after examining their books. After Harry Potter, i needed, like everybody else, to be like Hermione. I studied extra frequently, I spoke in a crappy British accessory, and that i even went so a ways as to repeatedly boss my acquaintances around. Thank goodness that section ended. I examine Huckleberry Finn, and commenced to talk in simple terms like Huck. I stated "I reckon" lots. a minimum of my southern accessory became extra perfect than my British accessory. Then I examine One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. It occurs in a psychological asylum. i will permit you artwork out how properly my impersonations of those characters went. hint: i began out speaking to myself. lots. ultimately, maximum these days I examine long gone with the Wind. i began out appearing like Scarlett O'Hara. i did not even comprehend i became doing it at first. yet I had her delight, her spoiled suggestions-set, and many different traits i could extremely not have had. I take on the personalities of most of the characters I examine. i'm in simple terms happy it is in no way everlasting.

Answer 6

People are to be blamed for their actions,not for being mentally ill.

Answer 7

First of all such people can not understand if someone is bleming them secondly they should not be left out by their family members other wise they may be victim of discrmination.

Answer 8

No. That's like blaming someone for being tall or short, blonde haired or black haired, blue eyes, brown eyes etc.

Answer 9

blame seems fruitless but accountable is a must to account is to keep track and what you track you can control