Who cares if we beat Guantanamo prisoners?

Question

The Pentagon is investigating claims of beatings at Gitmo, but who cares?

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20061007/ap_on_re_us/guantanamo_alleged_abuse

They are terrorists, and America has turned into a bunch of cowards. If we are invaded by China we will get destroyed.

Answer 1

I care, we are American and stand for a hell of a lot more then inhumain treatment of other human beings. They can be the worst people in the world but are still people. When we lower ourselves to their level we become them, and that is just wrong.

Answer 2

yet yet another LIE and FABRICATION by Erudite. somebody has already published the link to the actually tale, so I won't. besides the undeniable fact that, i visit make it sparkling and be conscious that Erudite has replaced words from the actually article. he's likewise added issues that are no longer in the actually tale. Yahoo enables him to do on the instant time after day. it rather is a criminal offense and could be suggested. Erudite is entitled to his opinion and he can protest the militia and strikes all he needs. besides the undeniable fact that, the way he does it rather is misguided. he's crammed with hate. He LIES and FABRICATES information thoughts all of the time. This ought to be stopped. finally, IF those Marines are accountable, they are going to pay the penalty. besides the undeniable fact that, militia or civilian, they are harmless until shown accountable. somewhat frankly after the strikes those terrorists have devoted against individuals, i'm useful what the guards did became no longer something extra beneficial than they deserved. that doesn't make it ideal, yet conflict is h*ll. IF the Marines did this, they are going to get carry of a ideal punishment.

Answer 3

Seems to me it's cowardly to beat defenseless prisoners. And they aren't all terrorists -- they are merely accused and in most cases nothing has been proven against them as they haven't been brought to trial. Some innocent people that have been released were beaten.

Anyone who believes that the US is supposed to by about justice and morality should care.

Answer 4

Probably the innocent muslims that have vowed allegiance for himself, and the rest of the males in his family to the Jihad since we(and I emphasize we) drug him out of his house in front of his family and tortured him.

Probably the soldiers that are captured or are in danger of being captured that will be denied Genevea Convention rights for sure now.

Probably YOU when Bush declares you an "enemy combatant" and your writ of habeus corpus is denied and your down in Gitmo wishing you had a clue about debating American politics.

See ya down there!!

Answer 5

I am completely against beatings --- I believe it is much more humane to tie an innocent person up, have 3 guys hold him down while a 4th saws his head off with a rusty knife. Isn't that what the terrorists do to American detainees?

Answer 6

Beating people doesn't give the United States a very good image.
We are the ones who are supposed to set a good example.

Answer 7

I for one care, and I care a lot!!!!
I fought and damn near died to make sure that YOU would always have due process should you ever be arrested, No difference guilty or innocent.

Now are you ready to give up the right for that due process???? That is what you are suggesting

Answer 8

If you don't care, read this. If you do care, read this. If you are human, bring a box of tissues.

If only it were black and white, but this certainly exposes the gray areas.

http://www.mojones.com/news/feature/2006/07/guantanamo.html

Answer 9

We should care. America used to be a beacon of human rights.

Answer 10

First in line would be our soldiers. Then their families. Then our Nation. Because believe it or not, other nations still follow our lead.