What younis khan did was right or wrong?

Question

if u dont know then i wud make clear
Younis was said to take captaincy since Inzy was banned for 4 matches.So there was another player selected in place of Inzy in this team. He was Faisal Iqbal.But Younis said that it was his team and he wanted Asif Kamal to b in his team in place of Inzy.
So he went to Pakis cricket chief but he overlooked the matter.And so Younis in anger gave up the captaincy.But there is also one point that Younis Khan did not wanted to b a dummy captain?'DUMMY CAPTAIN'?
Your views plz

Answer 1

i guess its coz of the senior players in the team...players like razzaq afridi n akhtar who r in the team for 9-10 years now, must have created some problem!! coz i personally feel players respect inzi very much...an they dun wana c a junior taking inzi's position....they will b happy under yousf or razzaq i feel!! by dummy, younis khan meant that he must be the permanent captain of the side..not when inzi is absent!! whihc is wrong from younis side!! lets wait for the dust to settle

Answer 2

I don't think he did any wrong. Though what he did seems very individualistic.

He wanted his man in the team, and there is nothing new in this for a captain in Cricket. And if the PCB didn't take notice of his views, he was left with no other option but to step down.

Some may say that he didn't want to be a dummy captain or temporary captain, who knows he was willing to do the same act to Inzy, what Rahul Dravid did to Sourav Ganguly!!1

Answer 3

hmm Now Muhammad Yousif is appointed as captain, but wht younis did is i think wrong though he cud be right for the player selcetion as faisal Kamal is good but more towards test game..., Younis has asked for three players, MIsbahul Haq, Naveed latif n Asim kamal, for this trophy but selectors have refused n so he did all that,
well i wud take it other way, whatever were the circumstances, like he is been refused or what, he shuld have given it a single thought that its time of crises, national team needed his captiancy as no doubt he is good in that n he can lead it besides he has the experince of captiancy too as compared to other players.......the selectors cud be wrong( i m not sure whether they r) but he must have taken it as a Pakistani, he shuldnt take it pesonal, it doent make any difference whether Faisal play or Asim kamal they r almost at the same level, not that much experinced to take the team to wining streak... they had choosen better among good , soooooo its was not big issue to take it that personal n leave team with another big problem, after The bloody Hair did,

now i wish Yousif should do it well, but this responsibility will effect his performance ( i hope it shount).....Younis was good in that regards that he can tackle with pressure..so i wud call it "selfish attitude"........well my analysis is upon wht i know till yet, but if some other reason is revealed so wud take it that way...

But pakistan is realy in crisis now.........God help them

Answer 4

In the past when Inzamam was not available, Yunis Khan has captained Pakistan Team. Hence it is not a new thing for him. Whatever may be the reason, his refusal to lead the team at the crucial stage is not at all fair according to me. By captaining the side in the Champions Trophy he could have proved his worth and would have been in contention for captaincy in future. He should have considered it as a pride to lead the national team in such an important tournament

Answer 5

i think younis khan is the right man 4 captaining the team. he did the right thing by stepping down after he felt that the selectors were not giving his opinion any weightage but coming back again was a bit strange.

Answer 6

ACTUALLY YOUNIS KAHN DID A BAD THING CUZ AT THIS VERY STAGE PAKISTAN IS IN A NEED OF A GOOD CAPTAIN WHO CAN HANDLE THE TEAM WELL AS INZI DID!
BUT,YOUNIS WANTS PEOPLE TO AGREE WITH ONLY WHAT HE SAYS AND HE WANTS TO SHOW HIS IMPORTANCE BY HIS ANGER! INSTEAD IT WILL MAKE MANY OF HIS FANS TO TURN AWAY THEIR FACES CUZ OF HIS SUCH BEHAVIOUR!

Answer 7

VERY BAD YOUNIS, YOU BEEN SELECTED BY BUNCH OF SELECTORS AS CAPTAIN, JUST THINK HOW MANY HAS GOT CHANCE BEING AS A CAPTAIN IN PAKISTAN TEAM.

Younis Khan did wrong, he was said to take captaincy by PCB. He should obey PCB till Inzi's return to International level matches. Whatever may be reasons ,he shouldnot say no to his own country. He may face many problems in future to maintain his position in Pakistan cricket team.

Answer 8

I guess what he did was wrong. He was given an oppurtunity and he refused it. The Pak team as such needs to look forward. Inzy is gonna retire soon. There should be some1 who can handle the reins after he is gone. That should happen soon. They should start experimenting this idea soon, otherwise, the transition will be a painful process for the whole team.

Answer 9

I think younis khan had someproblem with the administration only they know the truth and only time will tell who was right and who was wrong.but from what we know I think when you dont have a say its because you need to establish yourself as a captain but if you dont take the opportunity when it comes how will you establish yourself as a captain.

Answer 10

The Details in ur Question is wrong........The pLayer is ASIM KAMAL........instead of ASIF KAMAL..........


absolutely correct decission........ the former captain of pakistan IMRAn KHAn said younis took the correct decission.....................

As inmran Khan Has more experiance than us................................so there 4 i may say younis' decision was absulutely correct .....................

he is captain n he should select the team...............like IMRAN KHAN........