pakistan independence beneficial?

Question

Was the freedom of Pakistan more advantageous or disadvantageos overall?

Adv: Muslims got to live in peace in another country.
Disadv: Familes got seperated in the seperation on the countries. People got divided.

What else?

Answer 1

Well it was the right thing to do. And Eccentric sense you seem to have a lot of false claims , Here are your answers. do you all people think that there was peace between the muslims and the hindus before the partition? No, certainly not. the history is full of massacres of both Hindus and Muslims.

And what did you say there is no peace? my friend obviously you have never been to Pakistan so you claims are " Baseless" People dont kill there one another like the way you have mentioned. Look at NY and other cities where crime rate is significantly higher.

And India do you think it is not corrupt? then a small article should prove my point: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/15131460/

If the way the Pakistan was the way you describe it do you think the 15+ curore are nuts living there if that was the situation there?

And is India not full of terrorists as well?. And for your kind information Ghandi was working on freeing India from the British to form "Hindustan" Land of Hindus, not a country where both the muslims and the Hindus could live in Peace and that was the very reason he was assasinated from his own people.

I have been to both India and Pakistan and frankly paki people were a lot more friendly than the Indians.

Answer 2

Creation of Pakistan is totally a disadvantage to an ordinary people of this region. Just see where this state is: A total failure state. In the hands of a terrorist army who is destroying own people. When they can’t fight enemy they started conquering their own people. I think now USA and UK should realize what mistake they had done by dividing the united India. Now its time to reunite whole India into one country, Or to disintegrate Pakistan into four pieces.

But yes it is advantage to some minorities like PAK Army, khans, choudreys, nawabs etc and elite class of Pakistan and they have looted this country resources badly. While rest of 15 crore are living below poverty line.

You said advantage is that Muslim wants to live with peace, please tell me is there any peace in Pakistan? It is the only Muslim country in this world where an ordinary Muslim even can’t pray peacefully in their mosque as there is a fear that another Muslim will kill them. Simply tell me is there any such fear to Muslims in India (except few cities)
Just after its creation their Army kicked out Bengalis. Their army looted Bengal, raped their women, killed thousand of innocent Bengalis. Even now their army is killing and looting Baluch and Puhktun.

Doesn’t it’s a curse of God that 95% of the total population even don’t have one glass of clean water?

I think now time comes to give a choice again to all the people with whom they want to unite?

What else u want to hear?

I have lots of FACTS for u

Answer 3

Read up a bit on the pre and post era Partitioning. Standard divide and keep control politics of the Western world. Certainly not at all what Gandhi envisioned when he was working towards a free India.

Water under the bridge now, I'm afraid.

Answer 4

The independence of Pakistan resulted to separation of families which is the sacrifice that Pakistanis had to bear since in exchange for sovereignty.