The kind of communism offered by the Soviet Union, and arguably that of China failed. But is there anything?

Question

inherently evil about communism / socialism that does not deny people the right to practice their faith. One of the problems in past systems has been regimes that are corrupt, that steal money from the people even though the stated purpose is to have a classless society.
Of course the rich want to get richer, and that is one problem people will have with communism. But how about the idea of leaving nobody behind?

I can accept that communism is doomed by greed, but in that sense, how is it different from capitalism?
Take American capitalism, where our government seems to be helping businesses to sell us out to other countries.

Mr. Phattphatt, I not at all interested in meaningless, preaching answers like yours. I'm an American, but I think time has yet to tell if the American government works. It seems like they're good a great job of pissing away our future...

Answer 1

Actually the communist system, if it run the way it should be run is probably the best system of government that there is. But like you said, human nature is something that has to be dealt with like it or not.
Capitolism is the favored system of the individualist. If somebody is left behind...too bad for them. This system is just as corrupt as any communist or socialist system. But those at the top are living at such a high standard that they are unwilling to revolt.

Answer 2

Communism and socialism doesn't prevent people from practicing their faiths. Consider Cuba, it does not suppress religion. I just looked on just one, Church of Christ, which has a dozen there. I know JWs are there, and Catholics, yet Cuba is Communist. Until just recently, the Netherlands had Socialist government. Even Russia had the Russian Orthodox Church. IN fact, freedom of religion is more suppressed there now than when they were a Socialist Republic. The ROC wants all churches, except theirs, closed, and it has been happening.

The Netherlands had the best type of Socialist government, but in recent years, big money has pushed for a change back to capitalism.

Essentially, man cannot rule himself.

Answer 3

nicely in case you particularly need to get technical, then confident the ruling communist social gathering in the two countries have been never communist to initiate with. no is any communist u . s . the two. the communist manifesto from carl marx speaks of revolution, taking on and then disbanding the recent goverment and letting the persons goven themselves. so no the soviet union replaced into never a genuine communist u . s ., it replaced into basically ruled by using the communist social gathering. as far as china, no thats no longer communism thats maoism it is in step with communism different than for a stable considered necessary goverment looking after the persons. so thats no longer genuine communsim besides. in case you ask absolutely everyone which contains the persons of those 2 countries and the different countries that they lived below there administration they'll say that its communsim yet what do they comprehend besides as all of us else.

Answer 4

no govt can work with out God. The Love and Fear of God is why america worked.. A constitutional republic based on capitalism, full of athiests is more dangerous than a benevolent dictatorship with a Christ based ideology.. which is the way Christ will rule when He returns...The failure of communism is that it insists that government is god, and there is no room for the living and true God

Answer 5

Communism is terminally doomed by greed.