English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

You tell people humans came from a magic garden with an "apple tree of sin" growing in it. You belive people speak different languages because we tried to build a tower to heaven and god got mad. Your ancestors crusaded around murdering millions of people, spitting on your own crosses, warship severed heads, and preforming sick sexual acts. Your trusted priests are so convinced that homo$exuality is a choice they r@pe and molest thousands of boys in secrecy, not knowing how to confront their (obviously) unchosen affliction. Not to mention, you tell people who were borned and raised a different religon they will burn in a fire for the rest of time? .. I could go on forever, but like I asked are catholics completely nuts?

2006-10-03 19:39:49 · 20 answers · asked by Anonymous in Social Science Other - Social Science

20 answers

Yes, catholics are completely nuts, but you should get your facts straight before you post. First off, it was not an apple tree of sin, it was the tree of knowledge of good and bad. Second you cannot compare homosexuality with pedophilia. There is a very big difference. Homosexuality is practiced between 2 consenting adults but pedophilia among priests is the act of taking advantage of your position of authority to rob a child of their innocence. Yes catholics are nuts but it is just as insane to compare homosexuality with pedophilia. Not to mention that we can all agree that pedophilia is illegal and homosexuality is not.

2006-10-03 19:41:30 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 1 1

I think you have Catholics mixed up with Baptists there, Catholics have a much more moderate view since Vatican II, a change in practices and ideologies, not a sequel, where as the Baptists are the hardliners with their crap of yoking (people of like faiths marrying), going to hell for not being christian, and talking about the tower of babel. Yes Catholics are responsible for the crusades, a nice little 300 year period where it was claimed to be spreading the faith back to the holy lands, but ended up being a pillage fest. And yes there is a problem with priests and molestations, but that's true in almost any religion or adult/minor relationship, your going to have those adults who just can't keep their hands to themselves, the news just splatters it over the place because people put priests up on these pedestals and forget that they are human. I was raised catholic and I can tell you I was shocked at some of the things I was told by friends who were raised protestant and baptists and what is taught, and don't get me started on these new age churches, they are no better in their teachings than the baptists.

2006-10-03 19:56:29 · answer #2 · answered by Mark G 7 · 0 0

You ASK?

You tell people humans came from a magic garden with an "apple tree of sin" growing in it. You belive people speak different languages because we tried to build a tower to heaven and god got mad. Your ancestors crusaded around murdering millions of people, spitting on your own crosses, warship severed heads, and preforming sick sexual acts. Your trusted priests are so convinced that homo$exuality is a choice they r@pe and molest thousands of boys in secrecy, not knowing how to confront their (obviously) unchosen affliction. Not to mention, you tell people who were borned and raised a different religon they will burn in a fire for the rest of time? .. I could go on forever, but like I asked are catholics completely nuts?

The Answer is NO!!

2006-10-03 19:45:11 · answer #3 · answered by i_lyn_tek_i 4 · 0 4

no.
because I am agnostic.
but (for a brief time) an officially recognized catholic. I was baptized before I had any say in it and attended the church just long enough for some of the mass to have some emotional impact on my psyche. Its nostalgia to me.
As a group and an organization YES...is the overall effect...but no because you have to realize its one of those institutions left over from the dark ages...I honestly think they got by because they were basically the worlds #1 tool of psychological warfare employed by the Spanish for quite a long time. They have hierarchy and money pouring in just like any other gang of kooks.
Otherwise besides the few prolific bad apples we tend to see on the news rather than not see on the news these days it seems, the few that I know in my family are highly ethical people. They dont prescribe a 1to1 directly literal interpretation but that the tree represents something...adam n eve etc.
Also is the argument that in the end its better to have faith than none at all.
Far more dangerous a mind if you ask me...a born again christian who can go around all day doing whatever kind of sinning then go home at night and pray to Jesus, and feel good about thier conscience...because its all in Jesus' hands.

2006-10-03 19:51:01 · answer #4 · answered by jorluke 4 · 1 1

No, we're not nuts, nor are we myopic about the world we live in. We believe that God isn't about "magic", and that "the apple tree of sin" really existed simply because even in a perfect place, there has to be basic rules/guidelines to be followed.

In the rest of what you wrote, it is the rot from "the apple tree of sin" called 'PRIDE', which you seem to be focusing on. Yes, Roman Catholicism is far from being perfect and clean. You have to understand that our religion is both way and means towards what we believe and accept as our ultimate goal: Eternal Life with our God, when ever and where ever that will be.

Besides, the frailty of what you write is the human condition, which my religion is the best tool (not the only one) to help me become better.

Peace.

2006-10-03 20:03:09 · answer #5 · answered by batch93 3 · 0 0

First you will desire to examine the Bible slightly extra valuable your data are incorrect. As for the crusades, sure they have been incorrect, yet i don't think of absolutely everyone will attempt to cajole you they have been good. As for the few clergymen who did those unspeakable crimes, they'd desire to have been punished as quickly as their strikes got here to the attention of those in cost, even nonetheless it did not. not something could be achieved approximately that now and no person interior the Catholic Church feels in any way that what they achieved or the way it became into dealt with became into ok! i became into not born into the Church so i became into not raised "Be Catholic or burn in hell!" i understand many do have self assurance that the Catholic Church is the only genuine faith and the only thank you to get to heaven. I additionally understand much extra, inclusive of myself, that have self assurance there are a number of common how you will get to God, even outdoors the Catholic Church. And no we are actually not nuts!! you will discover undesirable human beings everywhere. i understand of lots Protestant church homes and school platforms who've had those comparable scandals! Majority of pedophiles are married adult men. Does this fact make all married adult men pedophiles? NO, not all clergymen are pedophiles and not all instructors sleep with their pupils!

2016-10-15 12:14:18 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

Catholicism is not only a religion, it's also a political engine.

Catholicism is okay by its own, but when associated with wealth and power, then it thinks it can dictate over the people and their chosen way of living. In that light, any religion, including Judaism and Christianity, that says it's the only exclusive pathway to God is completely, absolutely nucking futs.

2006-10-03 21:01:54 · answer #7 · answered by Siddy 4 · 0 0

Look at the man in the mausoleum burried underneath fine arts... Blood on his hands mouth and genitals and billions of people do not see the veil. They celebrate the cult of a crusified being... Blood cult is the name. Satanism is Rome and he still feels he's boss..... John Paul The Holy man... For the insult to Arabic world, I allowed myself a joke... Benedict can only be excused when he kisses the ground in every Arab country anywhere.

2006-10-03 20:30:30 · answer #8 · answered by Anonymous · 0 0

They are not nuts ! They developed the best money making scheme to ever be thought of !!! Give us your money 10% in fact or GOD WILL PUNISH YOU !!! Have you ever seen photos of the inside of the Vatican? That is not gold paint, that is real GOLD... SOLID

Thay have the best racket going, extorted money and ultimate power plus it is separated from the state.

This is the Mofia's dream !!! It couldn't possibly get any better for them...

2006-10-03 23:11:03 · answer #9 · answered by Anonymous · 2 0

No just misguided......but hey who are we to judge everyone will find out in their own time, about what will happen when they die. Until then, try to be good and kind to others, and you should have a relitively peaceful life without a need for religion, or a need to belive in something.

2006-10-03 19:56:18 · answer #10 · answered by Mintjulip 6 · 0 0

fedest.com, questions and answers