Mcnabb is the best QB in the NFL right?

Question

alot of people say payton manning and tom brady are the best, but visit this link to see a play they would never be able to do.http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aAehdvQX9No mcnabb can throw almost as well as peyton manning, and tom brady just sucks. after seeing the play on the link, do u still think manning and brady are better?

Answer 1

As of right now, McNabb is the best QB he has the top passe rating in the league, the most Td's and the most yards. We can now see how good brady is now that all his best receivers are gone. he now has the similar receivers that Mcnabb has had all the previous years. Mcnabb can run when needed, he has a solid arm that is accurate. He is also clutch. He led his team to 4 cofrence championship games where the losses were caused by injuries. Manning is the best passer but Mcnabb is the better all around QB. you have to remember that Manning has been surrounded by excellent receivers and running backs all his years. He has Marvin Harrison who will go into the hall of fame one day. Brady is out of the qestion. I beleive he simply manages the game and lets the defense and the running game win the game. Mcnabb has been called to do it by himself through heavy criticism.

Answer 2

I would have to answer your question with a no. I am assuming you mean of todays currently playing quarterbacks. That is a great play. But I have seen similiar plays before. Sure Manning nor Brady would probably not be able to do that play as they would probably throw the ball away, having confidence enought to know they can get the job done the next time they have the ball. Nor do they want to risk unnecessary injury. Manning has a strong arm and the ability to call the play at the line of scrimmage without anyones input. McNabb doesnt call his own plays. Plus Manning is accurate which is one of the most important aspects of a fquarterback. I mean you could say Michael Vick has a very strong arm but he does not have the accuracy to do the plays as well. Brady is accurate, not as strong an arm and that is what makes him good. He is also cool under pressure. It can also depend on what you define as the best. I define it as leadership, being cool under pressure, winning from behind, and of course their are the stats and the won lost record of the quarterbacks. Keep in mind also the quarterbacks need to have a good supporting cast too. I could also go back too the past greats that have played the game. With that in mind you would have to look at quarterbacks like Staubach, Bradshaw, Elway , Montana, Tarkenton, Aikman, Starr and a whole host of others that i havent mentioned. I will say this it was a great play, but a play i have seen before he did it.

Answer 3

After seeing the Jets game Sunday I'd have to say that Peyton is a far superior QB than Mcnabb. Yes, he can scramble better, but he just isn't as precise as Manning. Tom Brady is the only one of the 3 who has a Superbowl under his belt though. I think that was more because of the team than the QB though. All in all, I'd have to put Peyton on top unless Mcnabb can win a superbowl.

Answer 4

Ok, I'm not a fan of the Patriots, but Tom Brady sucks? Last time I checked, he had 3 rings, one of which he earned when McNabb choked on it, despite a huge performance from TO (Idiot but great). I don't care either way, but Manning and Brady are the two best in the league. Carson Palmer is not far behind. At BEST, I'd but McNabb at 4th.

Answer 5

McNabb is great but Peyton Manning is basically the Colts offensive coordinator too. Manning is the best qb in the nfl by far even though he cant make those amazing plays with his feet. It also doesnt hurt that he has better wrs than McNabb.

Answer 6

My God some of you guys are some right dull-witted dumbass idiots...........

McNabb has won ZERO Superbowls, Payton Manning also ZERO Superbowls!

Tom Brady has THREE.

Tom Brady is the best QB in the NFL. Period. (The question is NOT open to yer woosie "opinions!")

Professional Football is not synchronized swimming, its not figure skating, its not the Miss America Pageant! Its FOOTBALL!

In FOOTBALL there are NO points given for how "pretty" you throw the ball. There are NO points given for how handsome you look in your uniform, NOR for pass completion percentage, yards thrown, "scrambling ability." Or any other PANSYASS statistics! Not Gillette razors sold, or cheerleaders boinked or touchdowns scored!

The ONLY purpose in Professional Football is to WIN games, get into the playoffs, win playoff games and go to the SUPERBOWL! That is it! ALL the REST is of no more importance than what kind of sweaters the cheerleaders are wearing!

If you want to argue something else than WINNING the BIG GAMES, then you pussys go watch figure skating or free form gymnastics, or synchronized swimming, those are the sports for you types.

For REAL fans of REAL FOOTBALL, Tom Brady is the ONLY POSSIBLE answer to the question. THREE SUPERBOWLS, Get it?

Answer 7

Mcnabb is a good quarterback in his own right but Peyton overall is a better quarterback, he sees the field better and is a heck of alot better at throwing the ball from the pocket. If you watch Mcnabb closely he can definitely throw the ball but his best throws are when he is on the run, where is pocket throws are alot of the time short or too high.

Answer 8

Tom Brady sucks?


There is no quarterback in the NFL that can manage a game under pressure as well as Brady. Period.

Even Peyton Manning freezes under pressure.

Answer 9

Manning is best as far as a whole career. He is consistantly good every season with only a few bad games. Unfortunately, usually in the playoffs. Brady is a good leader on the field but usually surrounded by good talent. McNabb is the best athlete of them all but is too inconsistent.

Answer 10

McNabb is good in the West Coast system that the Eagles run. He is just starting to make deep throws this season. He mostly throws check off passes to Westbrook and L.J. Smith. He also doesn't seem to run the way he used to when he was younger. and still getting booed in Philly.