What article of the Constitution gives the feds the power to take money from ME to pay for YOUR health care?

Question

I have looked and looked and can't find it. And before you accuse me of being greedy and not wanting to help the poor, remember that we are a nation of laws and the overriding law is the Constitution. I am not a Constitutional scholar, but I have read that magnificent document many times and can't find ANYTHING that allows them to confiscate MY money to give it to YOU. In fact, the 10th Amendment SPECIFICALLY prohibits that action.

For those of you who are whining about the "45,000,000 without health coverage", know this--MOST ADULTS THAT DO NOT HAVE HEALTH COVERAGE CHOOSE NOT TO HAVE IT.

Answer 1

It doesn't.... Vote for the Fair Tax and screw the Dem's

Answer 2

So you believe that the 45 Million plus without healthcare should just live with the knowledge that, if they get sick, it will cost them tens of thousands of dollars out of their own pocket to get the same care that those with insurance can get? I think your question was answered above when you were told to read the 16th Amendment. Apparently you think the Constitution ends with the first 10 Amendments and the other 17 that are present do not matter? Also, I do not take money from anyone to pay for healthcare (except myself) and those who are on Medicaid/Medicare also do not take your money. They take the money the 16th Amendment gives the Federal Government the right to take. Also, Medicaid is a STATE program and the 10th Amendment gives all states the ability to tax its residents and businesses. Now, if you really want to decrease your tax burden think about this. Those who make the top 10% of the income pay less taxes when you correlate their contribution as compared tot he contribution of the working class American. When you take overall income and then work some math on their taxes, the richest American's pay roughly 2 to 5% of their income overall to taxes. (of course, those who are rich ALWAYS point out that their percentage is still the lions share of taxes) However, when you look at the average American Worker with a yearly salary of approximately 53,000 per year (AVERAGE MIND YOU!..that is removing the top 10% and including all those who are on welfare and make just 5.15 per hour plus tips) these people pay closer to 20% of their total income. This is the argument that is most important to taxation issues.

The rich get richer by not having to pay taxes and instead usually get their billion dollar wealth subsidized by government money while the working class pay 1/5 of their income to taxes in order to fund those crazy business subsidies.

(how is that for a liberal argument for you!?!)

The point is, TAXATION IS AS MESSED UP AS THE REST OF GOVERNMENT AND IS IN NEED OF SERIOUS OVERHAUL!

Answer 3

You apparently didn't read the 16th amendment.

"The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration".

This amendment was the direct result of a supreme court ruling in 1895 that said that income taxes were unconstitutional.

Answer 4

because they are lied to. before each little thing, Obama needs to make insurance better accessible to all. and modify the equipment so as that it really is more cost-effective, and also so as that the reassurance businesses locate it harder to get out of procuring therapy. The equipment he's featuring seems reminiscent of that which matches in Holland and Switzerland the position deepest businesses are inquisitive about providing insurance. second, of direction conventional well being-conceal sucks. it really is why we in Western Europe have it. we assume of, hmm, our healthcare equipment sucks. i recognize, lets keep it. i guess it really is an same with Japan and Canada besides. third, Obama campaigned on reforming the healthcare equipment. He stated he needed to make insurance better accessible and he became elected by skill of the yank human beings to attempt this. reality - the US has better lack of life costs for toddlers elderly below 5 than western eu international places with conventional well being insurance. reality - the rustic spends better on healthcare in accordance to man or woman than the different united states of america on the earth. that signifies that a useless American 4 12 months previous would have had a better suited probability of life in the adventure that they were born in Canada, France, Cuba, Germany, Japan etc, all of which have conventional well being insurance.

Answer 5

Amen!

I cannot help but think that without the passage of the godawful populist 17th Amendment, the socialism introduced by FDR would never have happened. When the state governments lost their voice in DC, there was nobody left to check the rampant growth of federal power.

Answer 6

I sure hope the best for you, as one of the 45 million without health care, I think that I know more then you about the subject. I hope that you never get to sick to work. I hope that you die a healthy person.

Answer 7

The Constitution has secretly been done away with a long time ago by THIS secret and evil group that has been in control of everything for way too long!...
http://www.rense.com/general58/suspre.htm
Here's where your money has REALLY been going!...
http://www.global-conspiracies.com/fema_concentration_camps.htm
http://www.gnn.tv/threads/9229/FEMA_DEATHCAMPS_AND_THE_RED_AND_BLUE_LIST_UNDER_MARTIAL_LAW
http://www.thepowerhour.com/news2/ftct.htm

Answer 8

Are you talking about taxation in general? Illegal immigrants getting health care? What? I'm confused.

Answer 9

Please be quite, we don't want the masses to know these things. Be calm and let us take care of things for you.
You can get free teachings on this subject from your local, tax payer funded, Liberal Essem Made Mandatory (LEMM) group.
Please give all you have.(or we will pass a law to make you)

Answer 10

ask democrats, theyre the experts in taking your money and giving it to people who dont work, but otherwise can work.