Is it morally wrong for people to protest the war at a soldiers funeral??

Question

Why would someone want to stoop to a all time moral low so the can exercise the freedom of speech...a funeral is a time where the family can say goodbye and should be allowed to grieve in peace....i am appalled that people would do this....how would they feel if people protested at there brother, child, sister, mother, fahter, etc. funeral.....im sure they would want the some respect shown.....so they could grieve in peace

Answer 1

The thing to remember is that a funeral is a private time for the family and friends to pay their last respects. The deceased is not in the equation and could not care less.

Anyone disrupting a funeral who does not number in the friends and family of the subject deserves to be beaten within an inch of his/her life so they are not tempted to repeat it.

If it happened at the funeral of any of my family I would not be responsible for my actions.

Answer 2

There is a time and a place for everything - and funerals are not the place to protest. The last thing a grieving family member needs is to see something like that.

As long as we're on the subject...I've been to a few funerals at Arlington Cemetery and I would like to ask anyone who visits to do a two things to show their respect.

1] Do not take pictures of funerals or mourners if you are not participating in the funeral. While it may be a public space it is upsetting to the mourners.

2] Dress appropriately. Although you are sight seeing this is a cemetery. Don't wear shorts and t-shirts and ball caps - it's not Disneyworld

Answer 3

I think it is wrong to protest at a soldier's funeral. Their family and friends deserve privacy and a time to grieve. If people want to protest thats their business, but they should have the respect enough not to do it at a funeral for a soldier who died while working for this country.

Answer 4

It is seriously disrespectful to protest at a soldier's funeral. He died in the line of duty...he was doing his job...he may not have been in favor of the war, but he did his job nothwithstanding. The family is there to grieve over the loss of their loved one and for friends to pay thier last respects to their dear friend. It is no place to bring anything political into. It is absolutely appalling for ANYONE to do this!! That soldier didn't want to die.

Answer 5

that's one hundred% morally incorrect to protest the conflict on the funeral of a soldier. Disagree with any conflict for any reason, even with the indisputable fact that that's no longer the soldier who made the alternative to bypass to conflict. squaddies obey orders and take care of the american human beings. in fact, the vast majority of adult males and women individuals in uniform are very anti-conflict. Do you truly imagine they favor to leave their households, bypass to a united states some distance away, carry a gun, and be put in a topic the position they could ought to kill someone they don't even understand? in case you sense that's okay to protest the conflict on the funeral of a soldier, or that that's okay to call squaddies "conflict-mongers" or "toddler-killers", keep in mind those options: that's the SOLDIER, no longer the structure, that supplies us freedom of speech. that's the SOLDIER, no longer the pastor, who supplies us freedom of religion. that's the SOLDIER, no longer the media, who supplies us freedom of the clicking. that's the SOLDIER, no longer the police, who protects our rights antagonistic to self-incrimination. that's the SOLDIER, no longer the judicial equipment, who protects our rights to due technique of regulation. that's the SOLDIER, the guy who respects the flag, salutes the flag, and honors the flag, that supplies our electorate the right to burn the flag. that's the SOLDIER, no longer the so-said as "divine suitable" of being an American, that enables us to stay in a society depending on the assure of human rights, fairly than the denial of human rights. So the subsequent time you come back to a call to undesirable-mouth the militia, keep in mind that you're spitting in the faces of the individuals who stand between you and oppression like you have not in any respect ordinary.

Answer 6

First, I am opposed to the war. However, I believe, whether or not it is morally wrong that protesting at a soldiers funeral is simply showing an astounding lack of class. most of the folks protesting at funerals are part of the group from Kansas. They are not anti war they are anti gay and very ugly about it. The believe that any soldier who serves in the military of this country supports the rights of gay citizens (I won't quote the language they are using) and therefore will burn in hell.

Answer 7

Yes, its morally wrong. It's not a free speech issue its a privacy issue. But if you're a leftist there is no right and wrong and no level of depravity to low to wallow in, for the opportunity to make your point.

I think you must look at the protesters and wonder. Do I want to be associated with a group like this.

Answer 8

As an ex-Marine who participated in the Vietnam war but who is also against the Iraqi war, I'd say it's morally wrong to make a protest as a soldier's funeral.
Doing so is an insult to the families involved, and it's yet another case where the end (protesting the war) does NOT justify the means.

Answer 9

I agree with you. The soldier was a person with family and loved ones that he choose to protect by serving his country. I don't think the protesters see that at all. That they are actually protected by people like the soldier who are willing to defend what is right. But it is the protesters main cry "that people are dying over there" that rallies them together. There are far better places and times to protest than at somebody's funeral. They should be banned.

Answer 10

Yes. It should be illegal also. The people who do this only care about themselves. If I caught someone protesting at a funeral, there would be violence. I would grab them and physically remove them from the premises.

I am sick of people who pervert the 1st Amendment to think they can say and do what they want.