what is the source of this quotation?

Question

"When someone speaks, the question to be asked is: who is speaking and from where?"
I thought it is from Marx's "German Ideology" but I cannot find it anywere in the book. I appreciate any suggestion. Thanks!

Answer 1

You're right :O)


In The Holy Family and The German Ideology Marx had already accused the Hegelians of the left—Feuerbach, Bauer, Stirner, etc.,—of having retained Hegel's language and his categories, but also for having returned to this side of Hegel, who tried to imagine himself in the world. in fact, the Hegelians of the left thought they were situated above the world and spoke from outside it, whereas according to Marx and he ardently insists upon it in The German Ideology when someone speaks, he should ask who is speaking and from where. The Hegelians of the left are in opposition to the reality of ideas which have no real basis: Bauer with his critical self-consciousness and Stirner with his egoistic individual which, Marx has shown, is not real and, in short, comes from a philosophical construction, just like Bauer's 'critical consciousness'. To know what one is speaking about, Marx very justifiably requires that one know who is speaking and from where: it is necessary to know that one always speaks from within a world from which comes the structure of consciousness of the one who is speaking and who, in order to know what he is saying, must know this world and this structuration at the risk of otherwise remaining within an ideology

Answer 2

No no, the quotations and resources are for a time period paper. The essay is judged on use of grammar and punctuation. Also, it's judged to your capacity to speak about YOUR factor of view at the discipline.

Answer 3

Read Atma Boodha

Answer 4

wow,you know better than every one here..