D' backs? Should homeboy have been called safe or out?

Answer 1

Probably out. The Padres home telecast never showed any definitive replay's, however. The only angles they showed really made it look like the runner was out. The Dback's home telecast, however, showed multiple angles and raised the question of whether Khalil Greene tagged the base in time. It looked like he was straddling the bag in an attempt to lay down a tag, but instead caught the ball and at the last moment swiped his foot across the bag.

It was a tough call, but definitely was blown for the wrong reason in the first place.

Answer 2

out