Drop Culpepper for Pennington?

Question

Generally speaking for the rest of the year, who would you rather have as a fantasy quarterback between the two? Besides CPep, my QB is Vick.

Answer 1

Wow. I would take Pennington, but realize he is an injury risk.

Answer 2

Culpepper looks washed up. Pennington may get better as the season goes on. Vick should be a receiver. If Philip Rivers o Drew Brees are available snatch one up. They're both gamers.

Answer 3

I had Culpepper and Vick until Sunday. Yes, do it. He has not done anything all year. There is no way he can turn around his game so fast that he will have any real value this seaon. He may play well this week, but don't let it fool you. He can't even throw 1 TD against the Titans for crying out loud.

Answer 4

Do it. Pennington has shown that he can produce, and Jerricho Cotchery is poised to have a great year. Also, the Jets have a non-existant run game, so Pennington will get better numbers with more oppurtunities (Interesting fact- Pennington has 0 INT in the Red Zone for his career.)

Answer 5

Give Culpepper some time, hes coming off a serious injury, still learning the offense, and trying to get in a rythym/chemistry with Chambers and McMichael and R. Brown. Plus his O line isnt helping much.

Start him this week vs. the Texans, if he doesn't improve, bench him don't drop him, and see how he plays as the season goes on.

Answer 6

Yeah, you need a REAL QB instead of Culpepper or Vick.

Answer 7

Geez you are in serious trouble at QB!! Can you waive another player in order to pick up Pennington? If you had all 3 QB's then you could go week to week and look at matchups.

Answer 8

Culpepper.
Pennington is still dealing with an injury!

Answer 9

yes