Big Trade! What do you think?

Question

I just got offered a Trade that i am thinkin about taking what do you guys think.
I Get:
D Stallworth and Carson Palmer
I Lose
T Brady and Larry Fitzgerald

I think Palmer would be a good upgrade but Stallworth missed the game against SF. If Leinert starts for Arizona in the near future I am concerned the team will become more run oriented.

Any and all suggestions are welcome


I have Grossman as a Backup and
Toomer, Horn, Holt, R Brown and Cotchery as WR

He also has Drew Bennett, Chambers and K Johnson. I could counteroffer for one of them rather Stallworth.

Answer 1

It is a bad trade because Stallworth is injury and don't need when he is going to be healthy to play. Carson Palmer is good but he hasn't had a great game yet. He threw 4 tds but threw 2 ints too and he doesn't have a lot of throwing yards. Look at it this way, Chad Johnson only in the endzone once and not really a factor.

Tom Brady is Tom Brady. This guy lead the Pats to 3 Superbowl wins. Also who in the divison is going to stop the Pats. Look at the Bengals divison, they can be stop by the Ravens or Steelers.
Larry Fitgerald is becoming a great WR. There is no one that is going to stop him in their divison. Look what he did against the 49ers and Rams. He had a okay game against the Seahawks. Also Fitzgerald puts up more numbers than Stallworth and he is much better.

So you shouldn't make the trade. Bennett has no QB, Chambers has not had a big game yet, and Keyshawn on the other is good. If you can get it to be Keyshawn and Pamler then you can consider a trade but you should just stick with Brady and Fitzgerald.

Answer 2

I would go for it. You have alot of depth at WR and Palmer will get you alot more points then Brady. Fitzgerald might be the better WR but if Stallworth is healthy he is in a better system with one of the best QBs in the NFL sending the ball his way.... I say go for it....

Answer 3

Go ahead man pull da trigger. Brady is struggling this year while Carson isnt it. With Mcnabb throwing to Stallworth hes just as good as Fitz. Take it b4 he changes his mind.

Answer 4

Yes yes do it, donte and Carson palmer will have big seasons, Tom brady lost his top 2 targets from last season, Larry fitzgerald is a good dump, he will be improductive this year with the addition of a rookie quarterback and Edgerrin James.

Answer 5

NOOOOOOO!!!!!! don't do the trade Keep Brady he is the best QB in the league and has Watson,Brown, and Caldwell to throw to and Larry is much better than Stallworth

Answer 6

If you can, get K Johnson, but whatever you can do to get Carson Palmer would be worth it.

Toomer, Horn and Holt are good starts (Toomer has been on fire this season).

Answer 7

I think I'd pass on this trade. Stallworth has started out hot, but he's never been consistently this good in his career. Plus he decided he couldn't go last week out of nowhere.

Answer 8

one hundred% Unfair commerce for the different participant it truly is reliable for you. Mcnabb is having a breakout 3 hundred and sixty 5 days. Boldin merely were given damage and is your league is a PPR league Andre Johnson will quickly be getting you an incredible style of receptions.Chris Johnson Splits time with lendale white and marion barber is a danger. Take the commerce

Answer 9

no way! brady is just as good as palmer and fitz is better than stallworth. donte is just hot right now but he'll cool down

Answer 10

Great trade. Palmer should keep your points flowing and Stalworth is on fire.

I see this question a lot btw.