If we didn't have a monetary system/barter system....?

Question

If everything on earth was shared from the beginning, and noone knew of the word greed...do you think we would have a more peaceful earth?Think about it...most wars/arguments etc are usually caused by greed.

Answer 1

Yes, truly. Except that the idea of sharing is a utopian concept when you think of different tribes, clans, and socio-geographic groups and other forms of population clusters having different needs, different skills and different resource base. One may have the pots but not the vegetables to cook into it. The other may have the vegetables but not the pot where these can be cooked. That is the most simplistic illustration on how trade developed. Now, for the case of a tribe who has neither the pots or the vegetables and needs both, it will have to take by force, having nothing much to offer by exchange. Thus there is war, where there is the "to the victor, the spoils" cliche.

The primary motive behind all wars is mainly economic, just as the main object of colonization is not to spread civilization but to have additional territories for natural and human resouces that can be exploited.

A few references:
http://www.army.mil/professionalwriting/volumes/volume1/december_2003/12_03_2.html
http://www.utm.edu/research/iep/w/war.htm
http://www.pugwash.org/reports/pac/pac256/WG2draft1.htm

Answer 2

But someone will always have something that you want and vice versa. There isn't enough of everything for every person. And without money or bartering, who would make and tend to these items?
We should def bring back bartering though and get rid of credit. Credit is what turned the world upside down.

Answer 3

It would be impossible to share everything on earth and most wars are started by ignorance, not greed.

Answer 4

Yeah anarchists mutually with myself have been attempting to convince human beings of this for hundreds of years, yet they gained't have a bar of it.Greed and violence might nonetheless exist, yet in smaller societies, the place community justice become meted out they may well be ostracised and flounder and not making use of a supporter community. consequently the deterrent cost of our justice equipment may well be far extra powerful than the present ones are. additionally each and all of the useful people who could fiix machines and improve issues may well be residing better lives than the ineffective human beings whose in easy terms skills lie in ordering others approximately might could get off their fat duffs and carry out a little graft for his or her each and daily bread, and that i unquestionably do like that concept lots.