vinyl,cd or mp3 whats the purist?

Answer 1

THIS IS WHAT IVE BEEN WAITING FOR... the answer is vinyl, vinyl, vinyl get yourself a turntable...

Answer 2

The purist is vinyl, the next best is CD and Mp3 is the poorest quality. Vinyl is analog wereas CD (wave files) and Mp3 are digital. Sound, by definition is also analog so when you record to vinyl, no sound quality is lost. On a Cd, it takes the analog material and makes it digital and some sound quality is lost. Mp3 files are made to be much smaller than Cd (wave files) so there is even more information missing, making poorer quality sound on an Mp3. Think of it this way, as the file gets smaller, you must lose some quality along the way.

Answer 3

Vinyl is. Vinyl recordings were made by recording soundwaves directly onto the vinyl disc, with the grooves in vinyl etched out from the actual sound waves. Everything that is played back through a vinyl disc is an exact duplication of the actual sound movement. One caveat to that is the quality from the recording of vinyl record greatly impacts the sound. Thicker vinyl discs record and reproduce better sound. Vinyl is also analog.

CD's, MP3's all use digital compression to record the music. Digital techonology translates information into a series of 1's and 0's. Thus what you hear reproduced from any digital medium is just a technological representation of what was, thus not a direct translation of the soundwaves like a vinyl record.

Answer 4

vinyl is the purist but having said that records weren't always made of vinyl either. 78rpm records, though later made of vinyl (thicker than 45rpm's) were originally made of a shellac resin. You only had to cough and they'd break!....well almost. If you get a 78rpm record in good condition and play it on a good quality wind up gramophone the sound is just amazing,.....excellent. I have a 78rpm Elvis record "Dont'cha think it's time" and it sounds superb. You could swear you were actually back in time and it was the 1950's. Not so with the same track on CD or MP3, no feeling at all.

Answer 5

Vinyl has the potential to be the best but it depends on the individual pressing quality to an enormous extent.
For example, a good 12" single can rival CD for dynamics and high end detail, whereas an LP with 16 tracks crammed on to it will inevitably have low pressing volume, terrible dynamic range and poor frequency response.
I often prefer to listen to a crackly vinyl original than a commercial dubbed-to-CD version with horrible amounts of noise gating to try and reduce the hiss and noise, resulting in a very hard to enjoy sound.

MP3 can also sound extremely good if done on a decent encoder and the bitrate as high as possible (256 or 320k for archival purposes).

How about tape?

Metal position cassettes with Dolby C gives superb results on a decent deck.

Answer 6

Vinyl is the purest but I would say only a professional or a really serious music lover with top class equipment could appreciate the difference. Vinyl inevitably deteriorates over time with playing.

Answer 7

I believe you approximately Blink-182. I used to hearken to them plenty and each as quickly as and a on the same time as whilst ever I pay attention them it makes me experience so reliable on the subject of the techniques I had whilst (no longer attempting to be cliche) i replaced into happy and once I enjoyed them. Rancid is an extremely reliable band besides. often the music that doesn't fit my favored form could merely be like the softer stuff on my iTunes. For examples: The Decemberists Joanna Newsom Josh Ritter extraordinary Eyes Elliott Smith Sufjan Stevens (he has a suitable christmas album by using ways) yet my admired bands are often gadget Nirvana Alice In Chains Pusifer Sleater-Kinney a suitable Circle and so on. and so on.

Answer 8

The most purist is vynil.. but if you want good quality go for MP3 or M4A

Answer 9

MP3s are perfect if you get them from a reputable site like iTunes. Sometimes when you download them from those free sites like kazaa or limewire they can be distorted or the wrong song.

Answer 10

Separation on vinyl is unique!!