Should children be smacked by their parents?

Question

Are people who smack their kids justified, or do they do it because they are frustrated and angry and don't know how to resolve family issues without getting physical?

Are children who get smacked more likely to do the same to their own kids?
What are your thoughts?

Answer 1

I was smacked on the behind if I did something really bad. I seemed to turn out OK. People who spank their kids out of frustration have a problem period and should seek help.

I have noticed as the fear of punishment has eroded from society the lack of respect has grown.

If all else fails a spanking could be in order.

Answer 2

There are so many different situations to take into account here. Are you talking about a person who once in a while gives their kid a smack on the hand or back side or someone who beats their kids on a daily basis? And why is that kid being punished?

Different kids need different forms of punishment. But that punishment should never turn into abuse. And you don't only have to use your hands to abuse a kid.

Answer 3

First of all, smacking someone because they did something you don't like is inappropriate. Why is it different if that person is your child? When a child misbehaves, a parent should respond in a well-considered way, not out of anger or frustration.

Secondly, smacking children doesn't work. It teaches them to be afraid or to be jumpy or to hide how they feel, but it doesn't turn them into children who know how to treat others and themselves well.

I disagree with the answer that "time-outs" don't work. I used them with my kids, who turned out great! If a parent is consistent in the use of time outs, and doesn't undermine the time out process by giving the child too much attention while they're in the time out, it's a very effective way to discipline.

Answer 4

Kids should not be smacked by all means and yes, kids who are abused will do the same to theirs/

A good punishment is always taking away the computer, cell phone, etc.

Answer 5

Smacking children doesn't send them the right message. It tells them that you don't know how to deal with stressful situations and yes, it will influence them later in life. Spanking may be different, however, as it seems to be slightly less impulsive. I don't have a firm stance on spanking but smacking on the spur of the moment is not the proper way to discipline kids.

Answer 6

I got smacked and never became a homicidal maniac.

Many who are in prison for violent crimes were not merely smacked, but severly mistreated. OR- never corrected at all.

It is one thing to smack and stop improper behavior. It's quite another to "resolve" family issues in the time-out chair, which rarely works.

Answer 7

No. Smacking happens when parents cannot control a situation in any other way. By smacking, you are teaching your child to react to adversity with violence. It offers no understanding as to why the child behaved badly in the first place. Bad. Bad. Bad.

Answer 8

of course it should be ok to smack your child,, if a child is in danger, eg,, plays with an electric plug, what do you do , you naughty boy that was not good,, or a smack on the hand with a stern warning,, well i would sooner have a live child and face the consequences of the do good-er government, who have no right what so ever to tell me as a mother how to bring up my child,, child cruelty will go on ,, no matter what the law dictates. get yer head out of Utopia,, and welcome to the real world, leave parenting to the parents,, just train your social workers to look out for the ones who are being abused, instead of tainting us all with the one brush. my mum and dad had six children, i would love to say they never lifted a finger, but by Christ, they reared six of us, we had our hidings, well deserved i might add, never did us any harm what so ever, we took our punishment, at the time we might of felt it was unfair, but we knew we were stood, they loved us, they taught us right from wrong. and now 50 years later. we have just buried my dad, six kids, 15 grandchildren and 7 great-grand children, he went out like a king, horse drawn carriage, he was our leader taught us the good way, . don't listen to the good doer's, trust in yourselves as parents, if it feel wrong for you , so be it,, but if like mum and dad,and my self, if what i do protects my child or grand child, keep your nose out

Answer 9

i do no longer imagine smacking a baby is gonna help them out in any respect. it truly is not gonna earn your appreciate, it is going to in reality earn your worry. trust me, many years down the line you could tell the adaptation interior the youngster between worry and appreciate. those that study by appreciate are more advantageous polite and understand their position. those with worry finally end up growing up hating their mothers and fathers and ought to finally end up hitting others to get their way, considering it truly is what they realized. i discover it terrible too. They in no way hit me a lot as a baby. they in reality smacked me on my hand some circumstances, yet those few circumstances are the in reality bits of my teens i undergo in ideas and that i nonetheless have pent-up anger because of it. it truly is authentic what you say, in the experience that they haven't any time to acceptable improve the youngster, do no longer have one in any respect! i do no longer have toddlers yet when I do, there'll be no smacking in my domicile. p.s. in a preschool the position i worked, the guideline changed into leave the youngster in outing for an same style of minutes as their age. ex: a 2 year previous, 2 minutes. it worked out completely.

Answer 10

Nobody is justified for smacking a child. I hate to see that done.
Many people deal with their children by lashing out physically or with verbal abuse. Bad parents haven't the patience to teach or train. They certainly haven't got sense enough to try to put themselves in the child's shoes.
I understand that child abuse is a behavior that is passed down. Very sad.