Who would win? Rogue or Super Girl?

Answer 1

They already did that, you know-- when Rogue drained Ms. Marvel, who was Marvel's answer to Supergirl. That's how Rogue gained her powers of flight and invunerability.) It also led to a convoluted plotline with Rogue having all the memories of Carol Danvers, and thinking that she was Carol for a while.

However, if we are talking Kara Zor-El, the Kryptonian Supergirl of DC Comics (whose secret identity is Linda Danvers), you must remember that she has two advantages over Rogue. One is that Superman has told her all about his battles with the Parasite, an energy draining villain that is probably the closest thing DC has to Rogue. Second, Supergirl has the powers of super speed and heat vision, with which she could avoid Rogue's attacks and fry her from a distance.

Rogue's only chance would be to take Supergirl by surprise, and even that might not work if Supergirl retained enough power to fight back.

Come to think of it, there was an old (sixties) story about Jimmy Olsen's super pet, a strange creature that was the pet of a beautiful alien girl who visited Earth and fell in love with Jimmy. The pet was actually the master, the girl was an android and the creature lived on the life energies of people who held his leash. He had forced the android to bring him to earth so he could feed. (Think of a one-person-at-a-time Galactus)

When Superman figured out the truth, he hit Jimmy with some sort of temporary aging compound. When Jimmy turned weak and feeble, the creature wanted someone else to hold his leash, someone who was full of young and healthy life energy. It made the mistake of putting its 'leash' into the hands of Superman. Superman just stood there for a few minutes, until the creature vaporized from being unable to contain Superman's infinite power.

Now, granted, this was the pre-Crisis Superman. But I wouldn't be surprised if the same sort of thing happened to Rogue, if she attacked Supergirl! So don't try it.

Hey! I just had an idea.... Rogue and Crusher Creel, the Absorbing Man...! Think they'd make a nice couple....? They could probably even get together, absorbing energy from each other, back and forth.... Hmmmm.

Answer 2

Rogue

Answer 3

Rogue because her powers are taciturn (meaning she needs to touch her just a moment or two). The problem is that she (Rogue) gets Supergirl's memories. Besides I love Rogue's hairstyle as well as her Southern charm.

Answer 4

i could be either if rogue mangies to to knock down sg then touch sg then she already has powers add on from sg's and she become blonde too See Rogues Current powers:

* Absorption of psyche and powers through skin to skin contact.
* Project heat and flame.
* Envelop herself in a fiery aura.
* Immunity to heat and radiation.
* Ability to see the infra-red specturm.
* Flight.
* Increased strength through focusing her flame powers inwards.
Look At Super Girls Powers Abilities Vast super strength, speed & stamina, various extra sensory and vision powers, invulnerability, flight. super girl has no chance of wining unless she found a way to defeat rogue without being touched
Rogue Wins Game Over!

Answer 5

Rogue cuz she can obsorb Super Girl's powers

Answer 6

If Rogue manages to absorb Super Girl's powers its all over for SG, but if she can keep her distance she could stand a chanch.

Answer 7

Rogue. She could just suck up Super Girl's powers and then beat her, if she had too.

Answer 8

rogue if she touched supergirl. If supergirl could blast away with heat viz or use something to knock the crap out of rogue then sg could pull it off.

Answer 9

supergirl... rogue can only do so much, as long as supergirl is aware of rogues capabilities and fighting styles, she can take her out witout effort

Answer 10

Neither...they would both be wiped out, as they sat on a curb in a mind meld listening to that garbage rap music, by a weak, drunk wino.

Hope this helps.