English Deutsch Français Italiano Español Português 繁體中文 Bahasa Indonesia Tiếng Việt ภาษาไทย
All categories

Can you explain why one tiny dose of something can be enough? I can't work out exactly how it works for treating behavioural problems.

2006-09-18 20:39:29 · 7 answers · asked by The Pink Wiggle 1 in Health Alternative Medicine

I have started seeing a homeopath for reasons I wont say, but was expecting a schedule as to how often the medication should be administered. Instead she just said to take it then in one dose and see her again in a few weeks. Just thought it was unusual that 2 little pills could help anything.

2006-09-18 21:10:18 · update #1

7 answers

Here are a few facts about Homeopathy :-

Law of Similiar

Homeopathy is a system of medicine founded on a definite law 'Similia Similibus Curantur' which means 'like cures like'. The word Homeopathy is a Greek derivation where 'homeos' means 'similar and pathos means 'suffering'. So Homeopathy may be defined as the therapeutic method of symptom-similarity. The recognition of this law was there even before Hahnemann. Paracelus, Hippocrates, and ancient ayurvedic texts have on occasions mentioned this law. But it was Hahnemann who recognized the universality of this law and lifted it from oblivion to make it the basis of a complete system of medicine.

According to this system, the choice of the medicine is fundamentally based on the principle that the medicine must have the capability of producing most similar symptoms of the disease to be cured in healthy persons. In aphorism 26 of 'Organon of Medicine', Hahnemann states this law: "A weaker dynamic affection is permanently extinguished in the living organism by a stronger one, if the latter (whilst differing in kind) is very similar to the former in its manifestations."


Law of Simplex - The Single Remedy

Hahnemann in aphorisms 272-274 of ' Organon of Medicine' states that only one single, simple medicinal substance is to be administered in a given case of time. This is due to the following reasons:

1. The homeopathic remedies were proved singly, and the Materia Medica was built up on the observed effects of drugs given singly, either in planned provings or in accidental provings.
2. Only one remedy can be the most similar at any given time to the condition of any given patient.
3. Moreover, if more than one remedy is used the doctor will never know which element was curative and our source of future guidance is obscured.
4. If more than one drug is given in one prescription the possibility of synergistic action cannot be ruled out, but it cannot be argued that the effect will be the sum total of the effects of the separate drugs. The ingredient drugs may even result in interactions that may have adverse effects in the body. A mixture of more than one remedy in a single dose would constitute a new remedy which would require to be proved as such for a proper estimate of its probable effects.


Law of Minimum

The suitableness of a medicine for any given case does not depend on its accurate homeopathic selection alone, but likewise on the proper size of dose too. Under this principle we give medicine to the patients in very minute doses. The minute dose means that quantity of a medicine which is though smallest in quantity produces the least possible excitation of the vital force and yet sufficient to effect the necessary change in it(§ 246). The quantity is minimum, yet appropriate, for a gentle remedial effect. This concept of minimum dose lead to the discovery of a practical process called potentisation. Administration of the minimum dose has the following advantages:

1. To avoid unwanted aggravation
2. The specific dynamic action which produces the uncommon, characteristic, distinguished symptoms of the drug, is produced by the minimum quantity of drug.
3. The smallness of the dose does not allow the drug to do any organic damage nor there is any risk of drug addiction and drug effects.
4. The concept of minimum dose can be verified by Arndt-Schultz law that small doses stimulate, medium doses paralyze and large doses kill. I other words, the action of small and very large doses of the same substance on living matter is opposite.
5. The Law of Least Action, formulated by Maupertius, the French mathematician, states : "The quantity of action necessary to affect any change in nature is the least possible, the decisive amount is always a minimum, an infinitesimal."

Health is a matter of perfect equilibrium, perfect balance, trifling circumstances may sway it, and so may it be balanced by the least possible in medication.
Doctrine of Drug Proving

In Homeopathy we prescribe only those medicines whose medicinal properties are known through 'drug proving'. Drug proving is a systematic investigation of pathogenic (disease-producing ) power of medicine on healthy human being of different ages, both sexes and of various constitutions. These recordings of drug proving give the only reliable knowledge of medicines which is very essential to cure disease homeopathically. Different medicines must be proved thoroughly in order to obtain full details of their curative properties. The drug must be proved on human beings because:

1. Animals do not give subjective or mental symptoms.
2. Effects of the same drug on animals and on human beings are different.
3. We do not get the modalities and finer symptoms in animal provings.

The drug must be proved on the healthy human being because:

1. The symptoms of the drug and the disease will be mixed together.
2. Moreover, the action of the drug on the sick person is different from normal person.


Theory of Chronic Disease

During the early age of homeopathic practice Hahnemann observed that in spite of best homeopathic treatment some cases would return with a recurrence of symptoms at intervals. This failure led him to investigate thoroughly a large number of chronic cases and after 12 years of observations he reached the conclusion that the chronic diseases are caused by chronic miasms. The miasms are Psora, Syphilis and Sycosis.

Psora is the real fundamental cause and producer of innumerable forms of disease. It is the mother of all diseases and at least 7/8th of all the chronic maladies spring from it while the remaining eighth spring from Syphilis and Sycosis. Cure is only possible by proper anti-miasmatic treatment.


Theory of Vital Force

It is Homeopathy which stresses the existence and operation of the vital force in a living organism. The human organism is a triune entity consisting of body, mind, and spirit. This spirit which is responsible for different manifestations of life was termed by Dr. Hahnemann as 'Vital Force'. Hahnemann speaks of the vital force in Aphorism 10 of his Organon of Medicine as : "The material organism without the vital force is capable of no sensation, no function, no self preservation; it derives all sensations, and performs all functions of life solely by means of the immaterial being (the vital force) which animates the material organism in health and disease."

In the healthy condition, it is the vital force which maintains normal functions and sensations of the organism. But when the vital force is primarily dynamically deranged by morbific influence, it causes abnormal sensations and functions which are manifested outwardly through the material body as abnormal signs and symptoms, the totality of which constitutes the disease.

Again if a cure is to be established it is the vital force that must arouse itself or be abided to arise for the recovery. If the vital force is too debilitated and exhausted then no medicinal aid is of help.


Doctrine of Drug Dynamisation

Homeopathic dynamisation is a process by which the medicinal properties which are latent in natural substances while in their crude state, become awakened and developed into activity to an incredible degree.

According to Dr. Stuart Close, "Homeopathic potentisation is a mathematico-mechanical process for the reduction, according to scale, of crude, inert or poisonous medicinal substances to a state of physical solubility, physiological assimilability and therapeutic activity and harmless, for use as homeopathic healing remedies."

Drugs are potentised by two methods:

1. Trituration - in case of insoluble substances.
2. Succussion - in case of soluble substances.

The objectives of potentisation in Homeopathy are:

1. To reduce the medicinal substance which helps to avoid unwanted medicinal aggravations and side effects.
2. Homeopathy believes that vital force is dynamic in nature and that is affected by disease, can only be cured by the dynamic power of serviceable medicine, not by its material quantity.
3. By this process the most virulent and deadly poisons are not only rendered harmless, but are transformed into beneficial healing remedies.
4. Substances which are medicinally inert in their crude natural state are thus rendered active and effective for healing the sick.
5. The medicinal qualities of other drugs which are more or less active in their natural state are enhanced and their sphere of action is broadened by this process.
6. The action of potentised medicines is deeper, longer and more wide-spread.
**********************************************************************
I hope this explains to your satisfaction the Miracle Named Homeopathy !
Nothing works better !
Take Care and God Bless !

2006-09-18 22:00:03 · answer #1 · answered by Anonymous · 6 3

Homeopathy treats symptoms with an extremely diluted form of some natural substance which, if given in way bigger quantities, would cause those symptoms.

The idea is that by giving those small does over time, the body will build up it's immunity against the symptoms being treated.

I have a state-of-the-art medical book form around 1920. It is all about homeopathy. It was the best treatment available until aspirin and antibiotics.

2006-09-18 20:56:51 · answer #2 · answered by Susan M 7 · 6 1

Homeopathy is among the most popular alternative therapies in the United States, and even more popular in Europe and Canada where such "remedies" can be found side-by-side with conventional drugs in many pharmacies. It’s used worldwide not only by homeopaths, but by some medical doctors as well as naturopaths, chiropractors, herbalists, midwives and sometimes even veterinarians.

No one can explain how it works – or how it could work. One homeopathic theory is that the molecules of the remedy substance leave an energy "memory" as they disappear, somewhat like a shadow, and that the body responds to it.


it is not class or course .
a breif narraeted.

2006-09-18 20:50:20 · answer #3 · answered by veerabhadrasarma m 7 · 7 1

Homeopathy views a sick person as having a dynamic disturbance in a hypothetical "vital force," and so reject the standard medical diagnoses of named diseases. The results of many medical trials show no difference between homeopathic treatments and placebosbut others give positive results.However, many of these trials have methodological problems, and better-quality trials are more likely to give negative resultsAdditionally, cases have been reported of life-threatening illness resulting from attempts to treat serious conditions solely with homeopathic remedies.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homeopathy

2006-09-18 20:42:38 · answer #4 · answered by eunice 3 · 7 0

But the good thing about Homeopathy is there are no side effects.

2006-09-18 21:00:17 · answer #5 · answered by Anonymous · 6 1

In times when the medical practise is not even thought of,our elders have to find cure to any illnesses, they would venture out in the woods and in the backyard to gather leaves that they think will help cure us. And this medicinal experiments sometimes come out successfull and its values are shared to other relatives and friends as well. Visit the Philippines and discover the wonders of the Pito pito...

2006-09-18 20:53:04 · answer #6 · answered by Anonymous · 2 7

It is nonsense.
Some excellent article on its history and dubious claims here.

http://www.quackwatch.org/

2006-09-18 20:46:50 · answer #7 · answered by Anonymous · 2 8

fedest.com, questions and answers