If a tree falls in the middle of a Forrest with no one or anything around to hear it, does it make a sound?

Question

I have heard this question a million times, I just wanna know the answer. I know what your thinking, it's one of those unanswerable questions, but I believe questions are there to be answered, you don't hafta tell me a fact, just tell me watcha think!

Answer 1

Of course it makes a sound, just because no one is there to hear it doesn't mean it doesn't make a sound. If you were there you would hear it so it makes a sound.

Answer 2

properly i artwork interior the tree marketplace, and that i will make it easier to know that each time I extremely have felled a tree interior the woods, or everywhere else for that count, it has constantly made a valid. I extremely have additionally seen animals react do to the sound a tree is making while it falls. so in spite of if there are no longer any human beings there to take heed to it, the animals can attest to it. and ultimately, i think of that's greater the landing of the tree that somewhat makes the noise fairly than the falling!!!

Answer 3

Yes,with any object that falls free or with inertia that collides with an unmovable object will create a sound/shock wave or percussion that will displace space and atmosphere,how far away or radius depends on the amount of energy involved. Besides, who's to say a squirrels not in the neighborhood to hear said scenario?This is base on the fact that deaf people can relate to music or their surroundings from vibration,that said what defines hearing?

Answer 4

If you put a tape recorder out there and a tree fell you could record it even if you was not there to hear it.. That statment is like saying it never fell because no one was there to see it fall. But the proof is there. So you could get the proof by recording the sounds.

Answer 5

If a tree falls in the middle of a forest, the sound waves, whether they are heard by anyone or not, will still exist. It's a matter of physics. Even if no one hears them, they will happen.

Toodles

Answer 6

Yes- according to science it has to make a noise. Just because nobody was there doesn't mean it didn't happen. Just like the atomospere, you can't see it but it is still there.

Answer 7

Of course it does. Did you know that everything living on this earth makes a noise?. Even if it falls down...........

Answer 8

Of course it does and if someone were there they would hear it. And seriously, this question sucks

Answer 9

technically it does but nobody will actually have proof about the sound but it will make a sound

Answer 10

Don't ask the same question twice. It is a waste of my time. Thanks for the 2 points!